Monday, January 26, 2015

Review: The Burning Sky

The Burning Sky by Sherry Thomas
The Elemental Trilogy #1
Publisher: Balzer + Bray
Release Date: September 17th, 2013
Source: Library
Date Read: 1/18/15 to 1/21/15
464 Pages
Rating: 


It all began with a ruined elixir and a bolt of lightning.

Iolanthe Seabourne is the greatest elemental mage of her generation—or so she's been told. The one prophesied for years to be the savior of The Realm. It is her duty and destiny to face and defeat the Bane, the most powerful tyrant and mage the world has ever known. This would be a suicide task for anyone, let alone a reluctant sixteen-year-old girl with no training.

Guided by his mother's visions and committed to avenging his family, Prince Titus has sworn to protect Iolanthe even as he prepares her for their battle with the Bane. But he makes the terrifying mistake of falling in love with the girl who should have been only a means to an end. Now, with the servants of the tyrant closing in, Titus must choose between his mission—and her life.

The Burning Sky—the first book in the Elemental Trilogy—is an electrifying and unforgettable novel of intrigue and adventure.

Goodreads | Amazon | B&N | Book Depository


So I read The Burning Sky because of the recent release of The Perilous Sea, and I have to say, well, it was kind of below my expectations. 

The Burning Sky takes place in another world, divided between the mage world and the non-mage world, kind of like in Harry Potter. Iolanthe is THE elemental mage, but she doesn't know it. She's being tracked by the powerful Bane and the Inquisitor. On the other hand, Prince Titus knows all this already, and he's created a huge, thought out plan to hide Iolanthe from everyone, even though he's never met her.

So basically, because of his mother's visions, he locates Iolanthe, hides her away in his all boys school in England, the non-mage world, and everything is fine. Kind of. But not really. Because he's training her to go up against the most powerful man in the mage world, the Bane, and Iolanthe is confused, Titus is confused by his feelings, and more importantly, I AM CONFUSED.


Yeah, for one, I was really confused in the beginning. I even read the blurb this time and even then. First off, Titus kept on called Iolanthe Fairfax, his made up name for the disguise. He kept on saying "You aren't Fairfax" or "This isn't Fairfax", because he assumed that Iolanthe was a boy in his visions. But nope, she's a girl. So that makes everything complicated for an all boys school, in London.

Second, WHAT IS THIS WORLD? I was so confused about the non-mage world and the mage world, and then I realized it was kind of like Harry Potter. But you can actually use magic in the non-mage world, and people can be exiled to that world as well. 

ALSO CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE MAGIC? Why does subtle magic sound so much more powerful and useful compared to elemental magic? Why is Iolanthe so important when she can't even overcome some subtle magic? There's a glossary at the back of the book with little numbers attached to each term or idea or just something that needed to be explained. I thought it took too much effort to go to the end each time, and it just interrupted my reading. I'm also pretty lazy and unmotivated ha.


But even with all of this, I still thought it was a good start to a series. I mean, it did start out very confusing, I really like how everything played out in the end. I liked Titus and Iolanthe as characters. Iolanthe, although not as confident, still takes matters into her own hands, and refuses to depend on the prince because she actually wants to help. Titus, on the other hand, wants to protect Iola at all costs, even if it means his own life. He tries really hard, and, I don't really know what his motives are, other than trusting his mother's visions. It just seems like he doesn't have many motives at all. But I'm assuming that will be in the next book right!

So yep, overall, it was a good start, even though it was very confusing in the beginning. I'm looking forward to the next book, which I borrowed from the library so woo. 

Comments (25)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'm just confused reading this! Also, can someone tell me how in the world to pronounce that name???

I'm glad you enjoyed this one and now I really want to get to it soon! I'd put off reading this book at first because of the whole "girl masquerading as a boy thing" for some reason that always just annoys me so much.

Can't wait to see your thoughts on the sequel! =)
My recent post Change, Change, Change...?
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Hahahha I just say Iola. Like "I-o-lan-th" Kind of. DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT.

The girl masquerading as a boy thing wasn't that bad. It's kind of the main thing overall, but most of the time is spent on fighting and magic and all that jazz. So I hope you do get to it one day!
Hmm...I'm not sure about this one Val... I absolutely hate being confused when reading, so I'm not sure whether this would be for me or not. But I do love the sound of the magic and the characterization. I'm looking forward to seeing what you think on the sequel though! Thanks for sharing and, as always, fantastic review! <3 3
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Yeah I think this is the most confusing book beginning I have EVER read. Really. It's not even info dumpy, just confusing. I think if I knew it was confusing, I probably wouldn't have picked it up, but too late now. THANKS ZOE! :D :D
I just finished reading this a while back, and my thoughts are so mixed. And I agree. It was VERY confusing, for a while at least. But I still got impatient with it and didn't like it. But yeah, the magic part was kind of good, I guess and it's a good thing the girl-as-boy thing wasn't annoying. I'm glad you liked it, anyhow. Great review!
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
IT WAS. It was really only in the beginning, then it got less so. I need to stalk your review then and comment on that. Thanks Naban!!!!
Every review of this so far has said it's either super amazing or just okay. I have it on my Kindle and was so hyped up for it when I bought it, but never got round to it and it's still waiting for me! It's sad it didn't live up to your expectations, I may have to try and get round to it soon and see if it's as confusing as you say!
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
I think it would've been super amazing if I knew what was going on in the beginning! I say still read it one day and see what you think! Maybe if you're prepared you'll be less confused? Haha or maybe you'll just be better at piecing it together unlike me. I'll be looking forward to your thoughts if you read it!
The premise sounds really good, but I'm confused already and I haven't even read the book! I don't mind having some questions about things, but when it crosses the line into 'what the heck is going on'... you've lost me. But YAY for good characters! I really hope the sequel turns out to be so much better :D
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Hahaha I know right? Yeah I'm really hoping the sequel is better because I'll already know what's going on (I hope). That's kind of why I got it right away instead of waiting a year (though I'll have to for the last book I think)
All the confusion! Fantasy novels are always confusing at first even dystopians. I think the latter scenes would compensate to the confusion of the first scenes. I am going to try this series especially with that promising premise and world-building. But YAY YOU ENJOYED IT! Great review, Val!
My recent post I've Been Richelle Mead-ified: Bloodlines Series
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Yeah that's true. BUT SOME FANTASY NOVELS DO A GOOD JOB WITH EXPLAINING CLEARLY. I wish they all did that. Same with dystopians. Yayayyaya go try the series! I want to see what you think! Thanks Abby :D :D
Yeah, this book definitely could work on the world building. And I really didn't understand the whole Crucible thing, to be honest. But I really enjoyed the ending, and book 2 was an improvement imo. But the first 1/3 of that one was confusing as well, so I guess it's just a thing for this series.
My recent post Review: Zodiac by Romina Russell
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
ME NEITHER. I kind of just glazed through it because at that point I was done with the questions. I don't think it helps that the book started off with the crucible and the Prince because I was like "Sleeping Beauty what. what is going on..." I'm glad you think book 2 was an improvement, hopefully I think the same :D
Confusion is the worst. Motivation is the best! Too bad this book had confusion and no motivation. Library books are the best! Except I never really borrow from libraries, personal copies are better for me. Haha, yeps! Sorry it was under your expectations, though I bet the second book will be better. Hopefully. Elemental Magic is AWESOME! Can't beat that. Wonderful post!
My recent post Taylor Swift Challenge
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
HA MOTIVATION. I don't have much of that. Only sometimes. I'm hoping the second book is better, because I'll be reading this whole trilogy anyways so I might as well get through them all. I really love elemental magic, but this magic felt very similar to the magic in Harry Potter, but less developed :P

Thanks Erica!
Yes, the word-building is quite confusing and I still don't get it.. I wish they made a MAP. That is almost vital for most fantasy books (and it's pretty to look at)
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
YOU'RE RIGHT they didn't have a MAP! I don't even remember the places and stuff :/ And it's only been a week since I finished it? Ah well.
I have been hearing nothing but amazing things about this book, so your review is pretty refreshing and takes away the hype feeling that I've been getting for THE BURNING SKY. it all sounds a little confusing, and I haven't even READ this book, haha XD Also, the Titus assuming the girl was a boy sounds a little sexist for my liking *side eye*

But even so, I'm still quite interested in reading this one, just to see what everyone is talking about!

Great review, Valerie ^.^
My recent post Mini Reviews Volume #4
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Hahah I'm glad to hear that! It is pretty confusing, so if you ever pick it up just keep that mind. It wasn't sexist in a way, but kind of a circular thing. Here's what happened: Titus got a vision of "Fairfax" and assumed that his companion was a boy. But that was because in his vision, Iolanthe was dressed to look like a boy to fit in with the all-boys school. She was disguised because Titus saw in his vision that Iolanthe was a boy when she really wasn't and because he saw that he made a mistake which caused the vision to be the way it was....... IT'S JUST CONFUSING man.....

Thanks Chiara!!!
This book confuses the shitzz out of me as well. I think I read the first ten percent and I was like FUCK IT FUCK IT FUCK IT I AM NOT GOING AHEAD WITH THIS. I was just confused, man. And I hate it when I'm confused. I'm not even sure I want to retry this one, although I'm kinda happy you at least found a 3 star read in it. Better a 3 star than the raging she-hulk that I was!
My recent post ARC Review for The Sin Eater’s Daughter by Melinda Salisbury
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
HAHAHAHA DID YOU END UP FINISHING THIS FAYE??? Oh nope you didn't hahahah. Oh right I remember seeing that GR review of yours hahahahha. I think I would've given up too but I'm not too big on DNFs and I thought it would get better (which it did-ish)

I would've loved your potential raging review though ahhahahahha if you wrote one though.
Ah yes, it sounds like this novel does have some pretty confusing concepts where you have to consult the glossary and everything. It's not something I can pick up everyday but I do enjoy slowing down and reading these books when it calls for it. I'm glad you still managed to enjoy it Val!
My recent post The Sky So Heavy by Claire Zorn Review: Fact or Fiction?
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Thanks Jeann! I think I should've looked back at the glossary from time to time, but I was just too lazy. I'm going to try to read the second book more slowly though. :)
haha sorry i can't help but chuckle at your aggravations with the book. Now I will definitely not buy the second book before I read this first book like I normally would (removing from wishlist now)
My recent post Tour & Giveaway: How do you take your fantasy? One Lump or Two?

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.