Monday, January 5, 2015

Nessie Reviews ☆ The Golem and the Jinni

The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker
Publisher: HarperCollins
Release Date: April 23rd, 2013
Source: Bought
Date Read: 11/29/14 to 12/30/14
496 Pages
Rating: 

Chava is a golem, a creature made of clay, brought to life by a disgraced rabbi who dabbles in dark Kabbalistic magic. When her master, the husband who commissioned her, dies at sea on the voyage from Poland, she is unmoored and adrift as the ship arrives in New York in 1899.

Ahmad is a jinni, a being of fire, born in the ancient Syrian desert. Trapped in an old copper flask by a Bedouin wizard centuries ago, he is released accidentally by a tinsmith in a Lower Manhattan shop. Though he is no longer imprisoned, Ahmad is not entirely free – an unbreakable band of iron binds him to the physical world.

The Golem and the Jinni is their magical, unforgettable story; unlikely friends whose tenuous attachment challenges their opposing natures – until the night a terrifying incident drives them back into their separate worlds. But a powerful threat will soon bring Chava and Ahmad together again, challenging their existence and forcing them to make a fateful choice.



Hey it's been a while, but I'm back and doing reviews for my dear bud Val, so expect to see a lot more of me this year!


This book was magical, touching, charming, and realistic all at once. I followed the lives of two mythical creatures as they made their way in late 19th century New York, and simultaneously found myself questioning some of silly things inherent in human nature. I loved this book. 

Chava is a golem, a creature made of earth and clay that was brought to life by her master on a voyage across the Atlantic. A golem is created in order to serve their master and can look into their minds and hear their desires. However her master died shortly after, leaving her alone and overwhelmed in New York city as her head is constantly filled with the wants, wishes, and hopes, of everyone in the city. Eventually she runs into a Jewish rabbi that takes her under his wing and teaches her how to pass as a human. 

Ahmad, is a jinni and the exact opposite of Chava. While Chava is essentially a child, the Ahmad is hundreds of years old. Chava is timid, cautious, and wants to help others, while Ahmad is a bit selfish, hedonistic, and cares little for how his actions might affect others. A golem is created by humans for the purpose of serving while jinnis have no master and even look down upon humans. Chava is made of earth while Ahmad is a being of fire untethered by anything. Well...until he got tricked into captivity by a wizard many, many years ago. Somehow his lamp ended up in a Syrian immigrant's tinsmith shop, and when he goes to fix it, the jinni is released. Used to a life of flitting from one pleasure to another he is greatly irritated by his new captivity as he begins to make a life for himself.

While Chava and Ahmad are the main characters, the story is told from many point of views and we are introduced to many characters. Initially, this diversions feel like little mini-side stories, introducing me to people in different countries or giving me a history and a minor character I had met earlier in the story. However, it didn't detract from the story at all for me, I was excited to learn about all these characters. It's not until closer to the end of the novel that I began to understand these character's importance to Chava and Ahmad's story. Overall the author has a masterful control over the story and I always felt safe in her hands. 

The only downside is that I felt like it took a lot of time for an actual plot to emerge. It was like two-thirds of the book was spent just observing Chava and Ahmad struggle and discover their way in New York city--which I didn't mind at all, because as I said earlier I loved them as characters. When the plot did finally show up it felt a bit rushed in comparison to the rest of the book. Which didn't bother me too much because THAT PLOT TWIST THOUGH OMG


In addition to the magical story, this book paints a realistic picture of the immigrant experience which I really enjoyed. It also left me pondering on some aspects of human nature, like why we cling to religion, or why we often don't act on our innermost desires, or why we risk so much for love.

I highly, highly recommend this book. It's not often I'd use the words quaint or charming or sweet to describe a book, but I feel they describe this book perfectly. Read it you won't be disappointed! I'll leave you with one of my favorite quotes from it.

He drew her close, the crown of her head beneath his cheek. Beyond the hansom's window, New York was an endless rhythm of walls and windows and doors, darkened alleys, flashes of sunlight. he thought, if he could pick a moment to be taken into the flask, a moment to live in endlessly, perhaps he would choose this one: the passing city, and the woman at his side.” 


Vanessa is Val's bestest buddy, and she will be guest posting ooccasionallybecause she loves to read and write. You can also find her at her own blog, Musings of an Aspiring Writer.

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I love love, LOVE Golem and the Jinni. This is my BEST read in 2013, suprassing everything else that I deemed 5 stars then. Like you, I loved Chava and Ahmad so much, that the snail like pace to allot for teh character development, I didn't mind them at all. It pleases me to know that you love this, too, Vanessa! ^^ I am so hoping for a sequel someday >.<
My recent post Potato Strip #3: Blog Theme/Design
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
I'm so so so glad to here that you loved this book too! Ughh I hope theres a sequel of them doing more cute stuff together ughhh I just love them so much.
I agree it did take awhile for the real plot to emerge for me as well but I definitely loved this one. It was so much more literary then some of the other fantasies I've read. Probably much to do with the setting and characters themselves. Normally the slower pace would have killed it for me but everything was just so well written and done that I still ate it up. =) Lovely review Vanessa!
My recent post Review: Under the Light by Laura Whitcomb
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Yeah, normally I would have been bored of the slow pace and put it down like 200 pages in, but somehow the characters and just how well it i written still kept me engaged. I was really surprised that I stuck with it so long, but ahh it's now definitely one of my favorite books. I'm glad you liked my review!
Hello Vanessa!! Nice to meet you (even if it's through blogging, it still counts, right?) this book sounds great, and the difference between the two sounds crazy! I have not read this, but it sounds awesome. ESPECIALLY THOSE PLOT TWISTS! :) Awesome. Glad that covered up the slow plot. Anyway, awesome review Vanessa! (Gonna check out your blog...right about...wait...NOW!) :D
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Nice meeting you too!! Thanks for reading my review and checking out my bloggy. And I hope you decided to read this book soon.
Hi, Vanessa! I love your hair :P THIS BOOK. I had no idea it looked so good. I mean yeah, I was interested and bought a copy but had no real motivation to read it, before reading this review. Very well-done! Diversity? Great! Multiple POVs? If it's not a nuisance to the story then fine! I just hope I will feel connected to the main ones otherwise it would be a shame. It looks fabulous. Lovely review :)

PS. I love this: ''I followed the lives of two mythical creatures as they made their way in late 19th century New York, and simultaneously found myself questioning some of silly things inherent in human nature.''

I will definitely read this book.
My recent post Review: The Darkest Part of the Forest by Holly Black
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
I'm happy I was able to motivate you to read this book, I promise you that you will fall helplessly in love with the main characters so don't worry about that. Thanks for the compliment and thanks for reading my review!
I've always been curious about this book. I must admit that I wasn't at all interested in a Genie in a Bottle retelling, but I'm glad it's not even close. This ain't no Disney!
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Yesss it's nothing that you would have expected, especially after hearing that there's a jinni involved. Pick up a copy soon! :)
To be honest, I thought this book would have turned out to be a dark and mysterious read, but looks like it was the exact opposite! Not that I'm complaining -- it's nice once in a while to read a fairly light-hearted fantasy, in my opinion. :D And I'm so glad you enjoyed this, Vanessa! The Golem and the Jinni sounds so original and unique, it's going to be hard for me to resist the next time I decide to go book shopping, haha.

I think the only really big problem so far is that the story is told from multiple perspectives. I tend to be really wary of that because most of the time it makes it so hard to connect with the characters, since we're reading from so many POVs. And I can't properly enjoy a story if I don't feel a connection with the characters (yup, I'm quite a character-oriented person). Luckily it still sounds like you were able to love Chara and Ahmad as characters. :) And I do like how it feels like several mini-stories all joining up to form one huge one, too. Don't think that's too easy to do, so it's impressive!

"It was like two-thirds of the book was spent just observing Chava and Ahmad struggle and discover their way in New York city" -- Okay, I LIED IN MY PREVIOUS PARAGRAPH because I'm even more afraid of this. I'm probably the most impatient reader out there, and if a story doesn't grab my attention from the get-go, it's likely I'll give up on it. I KNOW, I'M AWFUL. So if I decide to give this a try, I might not even make it past a third of the book if it's too boring! *cries* But who knows, I might like Chara and Ahmed so much, like you did, that I wouldn't mind. xP

Anyways, thanks for the informative review! Super happy that this one lived up to your expectations. I'll keep it in mind if I ever want to read something magical and charming! :)
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Yesssss read it! It is such an adorable story and just brings up so many happy feelings in me. And your fears are totally justified because having too many characters and taking forever to introduce a plot are 2 of the main reasons I give up on reading some books. But i promise you this book is amazing even with all that. I don't know how she manages to do it, but somehow she does. Thanks for reading my review!
I have this book on my shelves but I have to admit, I haven't picked it up yet! I love how it's quite deep and questions the parts of human nature, and exploring it form two very different characters would be interesting too. Lovely review Vanessa!
My recent post All the Bright Places by Jennifer Niven Review: Crying All the Tears
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
I'm glad you liked my review and yes read it soon!!

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.