Tuesday, February 10, 2015

Top Ten Tuesday #43

Hosted by the Broke and the Bookish!


Top Ten Things I Like/Dislike When It Comes to Romance In Books

Wow. I think this topic was MADE for me. Honestly. I'm not a huge fan of romance because I'm not that romantic of a person. When I was younger, I avoided books with romance or love interests because I was like "DUDE GIVE ME SOME PLOT" and I didn't view romance as a plot. And even now, I'm kind of iffy about it. Because with romance comes drama, and I do not do drama at all. 

But if I were to REALLY CONSIDER what I like and dislike about romance, welllll...


Slow burn - I love slow burn, just because there is actually TIME to develop the romance. And every time the couple is not together, I want them to be together. Also, usually when there's a slow burn romance, the plot is better, because there's more focus on the plot. So bam. Two birds with one stone.

Secrets, secrets, secrets - When MC has this HUGE secret that she has to keep hidden, and MC love interest finds out, which brings the both of them closer. Well, it has to be a good secret, like in Seraphina or Golden Son

Hate then love - When the main characters hate each other, but THEN BAM, they get closer and they realize that they can never live without each other. Like in This Shattered World.

Fake relationships - To be honest I've only read one book with a fake relationship, The Art of Lainey, but it was a lot of fun, and I really enjoyed it. 

The dark and forbidden relationship - Keyword dark here! Haha. I would love to read more of these, but I guess the closest I can come up with is Shadow and Bone, the relationship between The Darkling and Alina. I don't necessarily ship it, but I like the whole aspect behind it. I need to read more books where there's a relationship between the hero and the villain, IS THERE SUCH A THING OUT THERE? 











Not a fan of randomly placed love triangles - Or love squares for that matter. Like in this one book, The Winter People, I could not stand the fact that there was three guy interests that I could NOT differentiate between. No. That was not necessary.

Some good looking guy, who's typical - This also applies to the other gender, depending on the MC gender. Anyways, this counts as a romance thing right? Where the love interest is just good looking, and that's his only personality trait. There's nothing else going on for him or her. This was the case for Suspicion, which I recently read.

I'm going to get with this guy because he's here - Also applies the other way around. I really don't like it when two characters get together just because they can, and it's convenient because it fits some YA mold. NEWSFLASH. There does NOT have to be a relationship or a romance in YA. Contrary to popular belief, not all of us want a romance!

Instalove - Ah yes, the infamous instalove. Because. Honestly, why is this still a thing now? Why? Don't people know that relationships need to develop? Ahhh I can't blame anyone for this, I'm sure there are readers that love instalove. Also insta-attraction is a thing too. I'm not very good at telling the two apart.   

The fickle main character - I think this kind of goes with love triangles, but I'll put this here anyways. I'm not a fan of main characters that change their mind constantly about who they love. LIKE NO. Stick to one person please. Thanks


Hahah that was not hard for me at all. I'm definitely missing some, but I tried to limit it to what I've read and experienced for myself. 

How do you feel about these tropes?

Comments (44)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Oh, the fake relationships one! Such a god choice, I've read a couple books with that and I always love it! And do people really like instalove? Why!? =)

Hate then love is definitely awesome, the main one that pops in my head for that is Shatter Me, because Warner... *swoon*

I used to be the same way about romance and avoided it like a plague, now I'm a sucker for it though. Still, I hate it when it takes over the whole plot!
My recent post Let's Celebrate An Epic Unveiling! + Getting Rid Of A Pseudonym!
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
*pulls petals off a daisy* I love him, I love the other guy, I love him... I totally hate fickleness in romance, even though it applies to one of my favorite book heroines (Scarlett O'Hara. Hate then love is always one of my favorites, because it often leads to hilarious situations. I also hate instalove, but can sometimes fall for a lust-at-first-sight and/or soulmates trope.
Great list!
~Litha Nelle
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
OMG YES I LOVE LOVE LOOOOOVE SLOW BURNS AND HATE TO LOVE. IT'S EXACTLY WHAT MY PERCABETH SHIP IS. I HAVE NOW FURTHER PROVED THE BRILLIANCE OF MY SHIP. BOOM.

Awesome post, Val <3 3
My recent post 16 Signs That You’re More Obsessed With Your OTP Than Your Own Life
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
I agree with slow burn for sure. :) No instant love here. The longer, the better, as long as it doesn't involve drama. I hate drama. Like you said.

I'm not fond of hate then love either which is weird, I have a friend who is, but now that I think about it, I definitely get him liking that…

FAKE RELATIONSHIPS! I CAN'T BELIEVE I FORGOT THAT. I don't really like them because they tend to be predictable because I mean, you just KNOW what's going to happen.

I agree with all of your dislikes. :) I hate fickle main characters, ugh. It's like, come on, there has to be some indicator. Though I like love triangles where the character genuinely doesn't know who they love more/in 'that' way.
My recent post All The Things I Love and Hate In Romance Books
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
OMG I so agree with EVERYTHING you said!! I love the "hate then love" and the "slow burn", and insta-love? Just UGH.
My recent post &quot;Written in red&quot; - Anne Bishop
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Secrets are so overrated. :)
My recent post Temptation: Audible First of Series Sale
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Slow burn romances!! I LOVE them! And if they have awesome witty banter between the characters, even better :D And I really enjoy a good hate-to-love relationship! Insta-attraction is one thing... but insta-love... blergh!! NOPE! Great list, Val!
My recent post Romance in Books: My Likes and Dislikes
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Oh REPLICA by Jenna Black has a fake relationship - where the two main characters are engaged and pretend to everyone they are in love but in actuality they aren't. I really enjoyed it. Waiting for book 2 to arrive from bookoutlet.
My recent post Review: The Glass Arrow by Kristen Simmons
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Oh, I definitely dislike it as well when the love interest is good looking but doesn't really have a personality! Why? And instalove. Sigh. But I LOVE the slowly developing relationships as well -it's so adorable!- and the hate/love ones. One of my favorite series (The Others by Anne Bishop) has an extremely slow-developing romance but it doesn't seem too slow either.. Those types of romance are perfect to me :D
My recent post Personal Post #1: A Trip to the Biesbosch
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
The hate to love trope gives me life <3 I could read those stories all day long!

Oooohhh yes give me more complex and possibly unhealthy relationships. I really like seeing all the facets of those people and finding out if they end up being better or breaking up in the end.

WOOP THERE IT IS. Freaking Winter People.
My recent post Top Ten Romance Elements
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Slow burn rocks, and love triangles suck. Love SQUARE? My worst nightmare. :) I love love love hate then love!! Its so AMAZING. Wonderful! Typical guys are so....typical! We need...a NERD. A cute, adorable, NERD/ GEEK. Who loves BOOKS. I can see it now! Yes, this post was easy for me as well. I have quite a few opinions on love and hate. Could go on, and on, and on, and on...haha, great TTT!
My recent post Top Ten Things I Like/Dislike When It Comes To Romances In Books
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Slow burn is my absolute FAVORITE kind of romantic relationship in books! With slow-burning relationships, it's like you get to fall in love with the couple as they're falling in love with each other, and the entire reading experience is just so much more rewarding. And you're absolutely right--when it's a slow-burning relationship, you cannot WAIT for the next time they're together! I honestly feel so much more attached to bookish couples when they're slow-burn. (Can I just say: The Raven Cycle. !!!)

I also like it when I see people saying romance isn't required in YA fiction, because as a writer it's a good reminder for me. Currently I'm working on rewriting a WIP where my protagonist didn't even have a whisper of a crush in the whole first draft, and every so often I think, "Hm, maybe I should include a romantic side plot?" But not every book NEEDS a romance, so I try to remember that and only add in romance because I want it there, not because I think maybe it "should" be there, haha.

Also, if you like books with "fake relationships", maybe check out To All the Boys I've Loved Before by Jenny Han. It's got a major fake relationship, haha!
My recent post Roald Dahl: Children’s Author Extraordinaire
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Ugh, fickle MC's! Boo hiss!

So 4 out of your 5 likes made me think of Across a Star-Swept Sea, which I think means you need to read it! But first you have to read For Darkness Shows the Stars, because it takes places before and will help make the second book make more sense, even though it's different characters. They're both great books!
My recent post The Top 10 Things I Like/Dislike When It Comes To Romances In Books
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
I am intrigued by the fake romance! I so need to check that book out soon!
Missie @ A Flurry of Ponderings

My recent post Top Ten Tuesday with Top Ten Things I Like/Dislike When It Comes To Romances In Books
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
So true~ These days I get more excited when I learn that a book actually doesn't have any romance at all. Isn't that weird?! I love a romance like no other, but som any times they're all so rushed, that I want something to start extensively on friendship first :( I want to get to know the characters as they get to know each other and I want to see myself the aspects of them they would eventually fall in love with. I hope I made sense ><
My recent post Random Things in Motion #12: If you had the power to save the world, would you take that responsibility?
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
I am generally not a fan of romance in books, and it really peeves me that a lot of people think romance is necessary in YA. Still, if it actually adds to the conflict and it's not annoying or inappropriate, I don't mind it. Secrets in romances are pretty cool, especially because they add to the conflict, and I loved the secret in Seraphina.
My recent post When Music and Writing Collide
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Slow-burn romances are the absolute best. I always root for the forbidden romances, it's just more fun that way ;) Random love triangles are sooo annoying. WHY TORTUE US?! Nice post <3 3
My recent post ARC Review ~ Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Insta-love is just so unrealistic. I love hate/love relationships!! :D And slow burn, of course! Nice list, Valerie! The only thing I don't quite agree on is the ''fake relationships'' things. The only one I remember having read was...hmm, I don't even remember, but I have To All the Boys I've Loved Before in mind (was there a fake relationship in it?? I think so) and found it meh. Anyway, great post!!
My recent post Waiting on Wednesday (#8)
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
THIS is why I need to read The Winter People. So I can use it for Top Ten lists for the rest of time. Might as well throw Suspicion on the list for the same reason. And secrets is a good one! I love that! Very nice list :)
My recent post Books I’m Never Going to Review: Part Three
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
YES TO ALL OF THIS. Actually, if done right, any kind of romance can feel good, even instalove (e.g. Scarlet by Marissa Meyer), but most of the time even the aspects of romance that are nice turn awful because authors ruin them. > :(

1. We need more of these slow burning romances tbh. Like, the kind that creates SO MUCH chemistry until you just want the two characters to freaking kiss and cuddle with each other. I've come across many of those kinds of romances in manga, but in YA books? Not really. I've really only felt that way in the Shadow and Bone trilogy and maybe in Cinder. Prince Kaiiii. Hehe. But yup. Lots and lots of development is good.

2. OMG. YES. No, and the drama that leads up to it? If it's done in a good way then the cynical hopeless romantic in me will just be swooning away. And is it just the books I read, but is it mostly the guys who keep secrets most of the time?? It's so annoying. I mean, yeah, I guess it makes them "mysterious," but c'mon -- it's getting old. :/

3. Oh oh oh and especially if the two of them are sarcastic little sasses, right?! They argue a lot, swear each other out, drop sass-bombs all over each other, and then THEY REALIZE THAT THEY ACTUALLY LIKE EACH OTHER. Holy shit. I kind of want a romance like this for myself. The only thing is that they should remain their usual sassy self even after falling in love, and not turn all gooey-eyed for one another. Stay in character, people!

6. I am basically against all love triangles unless the slow burn happens. Now that I think about it, the Shadow and Bone trilogy had a love square. But here's the thing: IT ACTUALLY WORKED OUT. I didn't feel grossed out or annoyed by it at all because I pretty much shipped Alina with every single male character in the series. Leigh Bardugo is such a master of words and humans and human relationships and romance. *bows down* But in every other book? ALWAYS some stinking love triangle that's TOTALLY unnecessary and which has too much drama.

7. Oh my gosh, I am so sick of this trope, too. No, wait, you know which love interest I dislike even more? BROODY GUY WITH THE TORTURED PAST. *MEGA FACEPALM* And the protagonist who comes to "save" him? JUST AS BAD. Lookin' at you, NA books. And then all the steamy sexy scenes they have together later is just puke-worthy because there's really no chemistry between them at all.

8. Yep, totally hate it when authors add in romance just because. No, not all young adults lead romantic lives, and no, not all young adults want them, too. Some young adults want romance in their lives, but do they get it? Nope. *sad*

9. pls stop with this shit i die

The reason why I tend to pick on romance in YA books these days is because I have been irreversibly tortured by horrible romances throughout my reading career. I will never be the same hopeless romantic I was. :(
My recent post My Initial Thoughts Were Wrong: Red Queen, Victoria Aveyard
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Haha aw, I loved reading your answers :D I hate insta love in novels too, I'm surprised why people still like it, but I guess opinions differ. Slow burn romances are my favorite - Great post!
My recent post Red Queen Review ♥ Victoria Aveyard
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago
Yes, to all of this!! Hate-to-love is my weakness, and I adore slow burn romances. I hate irrelevant love triangles, and also those fickle main characters who can't decide BECAUSE IT'S JUST SO HARD. *rolls eyes* Give me a break.

YOU DID GOOD VAL. :P
My recent post Be My Valentine
1 reply · active 528 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.