Friday, July 10, 2015

Review: We All Looked Up

We All Looked Up by Tommy Wallach
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
Release Date: March 24th, 2015
Source: Library
Date Read: 7/7/15 to 7/9/15
384 pages
Rating: 1/2


Before the asteroid we let ourselves be defined by labels:
The athlete, the outcast, the slacker, the overachiever.

But then we all looked up and everything changed.

They said it would be here in two months. That gave us two months to leave our labels behind. Two months to become something bigger than what we'd been, something that would last even after the end.

Two months to really live.

Goodreads | Amazon | B&N | Book Depository

I'm not exactly sure how I feel about We All Looked Up. On one hand, I loved the characters, the chaos, and the development. But then on the other hand, I was dissatisfied. Where the hell was my conclusion?

The title pretty much sums up the plot of the book. Basically, a huge asteroid is hurtling towards Earth, and the probability of impact is high. In just two months, everyone might be dead.


This obviously comes as a shock. What would you do if you only had two months to live? Travel the world? Say goodbye to family? How about blowing up buildings, falling in love, and throwing an End of the World party? Well, that's basically what Peter, Anita, Eliza, and Andy end up doing. These four, being completely separate before the asteroid, end up coming together despite all of their differences.


The characters are genuine, 
but what really interested me was their development. 

For all of them, the coming of the end of the world ends up being a good thing. Well, almost a good thing. Once you realize that life is coming to an end, it's no surprise that everyone is discontent with at least some part of their life. Peter felt like his lifestyle wasn't bringing anything to the world. Anita hates the fact that she's only an investment to her parents. Eliza realized that she liked having friends. And Andy, well he was going after a girl that didn't even love him! The dynamics between all of them were interesting to watch.


The events were believable, except for some here and there.

Chaos everywhere? Yes. Sending people to prison for disturbing the peace? Yes that's pretty plausible, even if there are only two months left. Throwing an end of the world party? I guess so. Creating a Tumblr photography blog and having it go viral overnight? Yeah...ok, it is fiction. [spoiler] Dying over being beaten up? [spoiler] Uh, I'm not sure how serious it was, but this was just so sudden. At one point he was there, and the next he was not. I almost missed it!



I wanted a conclusion. I continued to read the book for a conclusion!

Did I get it? No, I did not. And because of that, I am sad. I mean fine, sure, it's probably better as an open ender, but that is totally not my style. Though I would have to say that my favorite part was Eliza's made up philosophy, which does tie in with the ending. So I'm not too bummed by the end.

Overall? I'm glad I read this. I didn't expect this to be absolutely AMAZING from reviews I've read months ago, but it was still an interesting topic to explore. Actually to be honest, every time I took a break, I almost believed that an actual asteroid was hurtling our own Earth. And then I remembered it was this book. Ha. 

Comments (34)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Alexandria Ang's avatar

Alexandria Ang · 508 weeks ago

OMGGG so does that mean there is a cliffhanger? HOLY BUTTCRAP this book sounds absolutely amazing and something I want to read more than ever. But that ending though.. no content conclusion so it's going to leave me yearning for more. Thanks for reviewing because I've been looking for a great review of this book.
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
hello VAAAAAL! *waveeeeeees*

I like reading apocalyptic or sci-fi-end-of-the-world books. These make me imagine and ponder on the possibilities of the future like zombie apocalypse, asteroids, alien invasion (I REALLY LIKE THIS IDEA). This book sounds cool and makes me want to make a list "WHAT TO DO FOR TWO MONTHS BEFORE OUR DOOM" the number one on that list would be to visit Ireland because ultimate travel goal :( (( Now I'm rambling. Anyway, it's sad that there's no conclusion at all, but atleast the book did surprise you in some aspect. I was also surprise with the tumblr photography blog. I have mixed feelings with that HAHAHA Great review, Val! x
My recent post The One With Firsts I Haven't Read
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Just damn it..
You confirmed what I was afraid of.
I wanna read this book so badly but I'm terrorized by the open ending, because I always need resolution when it comes to books.. But this sounds like such a wonderful and intense story!!! *doesn't know what to do*
My recent post Blogtour: SILVER IN THE BLOOD by Jessica Day George
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
It sounds like an okay read, but no conclusion. Well, that's frustrating. I might pass on this one, but thanks for the review!
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Great review! I liked this book but I found the general plot development a little too complex. I liked the coming of age stuff and I liked the big picture thought-provoking stuff but it didn't really bridge the gap between the two for me. But I loved the characters and the character development. I totally understand what you mean on the ending though. The uncertainty annoyed me but I'm going to assume it ended one way.
My recent post Book Review: A School for Unusual Girls by Kathleen Baldwin
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Enjoyed your review, Val. Open endings are such a pet peeve of mine and annoy me to no end. I seriously get mad at the author and feel like they copped out. LOL I don't want to have to wonder what happened or come to my own conclusion. I'm sure I'll be passing on that one for the ending alone. Glad I saw your review!
My recent post Throwback Thursday Review: The Infinite Moment of Us by Lauren Myracle
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
I hate it when books are like this. When you're actually digging the story and the concept of the book and yet it ends up being disappointing because it lacked something. In this case, a conclusion. That is frustrating and I hope that you're next book will be much more better!
My recent post HI GUYS. I'M ALIVE!
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
I really, really enjoyed this book (surprisingly!), even with its flaws. There was something about that sense of the inevitable, and the connections you form in the final days that just worked for me. For me, I didn't mind not having a proper conclusion, but I get that I'm in the minority there!
My recent post Review: The Glass Magician (The Paper Magician Trilogy #2) – Charlie N Holmberg
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
I agree with your [spoiler] [spoiler]! That was really random and sad and weird and I loved Eliza's made up philosophy. The tumblr part did seem a bit unrealistic, then again, maybe not any more so than four teens who had nothing to do with eachother coming together and finding out they were wrong about eachother and fall in love. All in the period of two months. :)
My recent post One Day I Will Take Pretty Pictures (The Bookshelf Tag)
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Sounds like a decent read! I'm glad you enjoyed this one! I have never heard of this book but you have piqued my interest :) I think that cover is meh tho :/ I would have never even considered this book if I hadn't read your review >< (I can't stop judging books by it covers.....)
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
This book was really thoughtful and self-reflective. It really made me think too about what I'd do if I only had two months left to live. I agree that the characters and their development was especially great! Yes, some of the events were pretty unbelievable.... Nice review!!

Rachel @ A Perfection Called Books
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Oh man, not having a conclusion to this book was frustrating wasn't it? But I guess the book kind of discussed what would happen either way. I thought going towards the end of world with some of the things they did were a bit lame though, as you said. Great review Val!
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
This is one of those books I WANT to read, but haven't prioritized. Honestly, I just want to buy it for that gorgeous cover. And I adore the spine (there aren't enough black-spined books on my shelves surprisingly enough). But, alas, I've also heard pretty meh things about it overall and that has made me a little nervous to pick it up. It's probably going to be a library book for me, and we'll see where it goes from there.

Ick, I'm not always a fan of open endings, either. There are some that work for the story/character, and there are others that just feel...lacking. Like the writer just didn't want to include an ending at all. I strongly dislike those!
My recent post Book Bloggers and Books Tag!
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Nicole @ TQC's avatar

Nicole @ TQC · 507 weeks ago

I plan on reading this one at some point. I am really looking forward to the character development so I'm glad to hear you loved that. I admit, you have me curious about the ending. I'll try to lower my expectations to perhaps save me some disappointment. Great review!
My recent post Stacking the Shelves (132) - July 11th
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Needless to say, we don't know whether all the characters lived or died? Boo. I don't like that at ll.
My recent post Hoarder, Books Edition: Episode 151
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
Interesting... the summary sounds kinda like the breakfast club, I've never read something like this and I might pass given the lack of conclusion - I hate that.

Emily @ Follow the Yellow Book Road
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago
There was a book like this that came out a while ago but that ended up getting mostly bad reviews. Very few people I know liked it which was why when I saw the blurb for this one, I was intrigued and hoped that this would nail it.

The reviews however seem to be pretty mixed and that makes me sad :/ I am glad you ended up enjoying this, Val and this gives me hope for the book. I do have a problem with open endings though (sometimes they work but mostly they don't) so I worry BUT WHATEVER.

Lovely review, hon!

My recent post Review: Ink and Bone by Rachel Caine – EVIL LIBRARY Y’ALL
1 reply · active 507 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.