Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Review: When Light Left Us

When Light Left Us by Leah Thomas
Publisher: Bloomsbury Children's
Release Date: February 13th, 2018
Source: Netgalley
Date Read: 1/23/18 to 1/25/18
416 pages


When the Vasquez siblings’ father left, it seemed nothing could remedy the absence in their lives . . . until a shimmering figure named Luz appeared in the canyon behind their house.

Luz filled the void. He shot hoops with seventeen-year-old Hank’s hands. He showed fourteen-year-old Ana cinematic beauty behind her eyelids. He spoke kindly to eight-year-old Milo. But then Luz left, too, and he took something from each of them. As a new school year begins, Ana, Hank, and Milo must carry on as if an alien presence never altered them. But how can they ever feel close to other people again when Luz changed everything about how they see the world and themselves?
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

It's times like these where I forget HOW to review a book. And especially one like this, which borders on the line between contemporary and science fiction. Some of the reasons why I picked this up were 1) written by Leah Thomas, who also wrote Because You'll Never Meet Me and 2) it reminds me of Shaun Hutchinson's We Are the Ants, which I loved, and 3) this is totally my type of book, and I wasn't wrong about that.

When Light Left Us is a strange story about three siblings who, for a short period of time, were connected to each other via an alien given the name "Luz". Apparently, according to the book, "luz" translates to "light" from Spanish to English, hence the title of this book. But rather than starting from the beginning, the novel begins once the alien has left the bodies of the three main characters, Ana, Hank, and Milo. We see how the siblings have to deal without Luz, who unfortunately did not leave them unscathed both mentally and physically.

To be honest, right from the start I was a bit wary, and the confusing beginning did not help whatsoever. Because the reader is introduced to the characters after Luz left, it's confusing as to why Ana is taping her eyes open because every blink hurts her, or that Milo needs headphones to escape the loudness of the silence. The writing itself felt convoluted, maybe to convey an air of strangeness; it felt like the author was trying way harder to make the writing more descriptive than it needed to be.

Yet, somehow, the more I read on and got to know the characters, the more I was invested. For once, there's a parent actually present and involved in her childrens' lives, Maggie. We also get chapters solely focused on her as well, which I actually enjoyed. The further along I got in the book, the more I learned about Ana's, Hank's, and Milo's struggles, and also how the presence of Luz affected them.

When Light Left Us does a phenomenal job weaving together a story that ties together real-world issues, with out of world issues. I've never read anything quite like this, and I'm pretty surprised that the story and the characters grew on me. The ending, like the book, was also a bit strange yet had some thrill to it, which I greatly appreciated but did not anticipate. The only thing really going against it is the weak and confusing start, but other than that it's two thumbs up from me!

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Yep yep agreed, lots of agreement! I was shocked at how much I ended up caring about the characters- and I seriously almost DNFed at the start! I do wish the ending had gone a bit differently, but it wasn't a dealbreaker or anything. I definitely loved the uniqueness too, it's hard to find a book where you're like "well THAT was different", but this book did that! Great review!
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
RIGHT! Like I think I thought I just wouldn't enjoy this, BUT THEN I DID BY THE END and everything was good. I actually liked the ending unlike you. I guess because it is my type of ending?
I've been looking forward to this book for a while! I adore Leah Thomas' Because You'll Never Meet Me and Nowhere Near You so I automatically want to read every book she writes. I've heard similar things from other reviewers for the beginning being confusing, which is a shame. But the concept sounds fascinating and peculiar, and I'm glad you got more invested as you carried on! I love the way the author writes her characters and how she parallels the contemporary with the speculative/sci-fi. Lovely review!
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
Yes I love how she intertwines the two genres as well. It is really refreshing to read because not many people write it. I hope you end up picking this up and loving it! It does help to mention that you just have to stick through the beginning!
It's got a nice cover too, that one definitely jumps out. I kinda want to read this one now, I'm really curious about why the alien would come to them and how they cope when she is gone. Good to know too about the beginning, sounds like you just have to stick with for a while. :)
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
Yes it's a great shade of purple! And yep if you do end up reading it, just push through the beginning!
I absolutely love love loved her first series but I remember being confused when I started Because You'll Never Meet Me as well. I think it was the mixture of science fiction realism that completely threw me. I'm really excited to read this one but it sounds as though it tries a little too hard to be strange. Maybe because that series was so successful, there's that pressure to go one better. Sorry you couldn't have enjoyed this a little more Val, will be a little more cautious when reading too. Brilliant review <3
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
Yeah I think her books are a bit confusing because she throws in these science fiction elements. I would say that this book is MORE confusing than Because You'll Never Meet Me, especially in the beginning. But then everything sorts itself out so it ends up all good. Thanks Kelly!! <3
Ooh this sounds really weird and also interesting?! I kind of adored the author's second book (the title escapes me😂 haha the sequel to Because You'll Never Meet me) and I do love Shaun Hutchinson...so I have to try this one! I'm worried about being confused though, because I can get confused by a title. (SEE ME TWO SECONDS AGO FORGETTING THE TITLE.) So hopefully I'll be able to library this one in case I don't like it.😂
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
Yeah definitely try this out first. And if you do feel like pushing through the confusing bits, it DOES get better. But if not then oh well haha. It's interesting hahaa.
Sounds like a really weird book. Weird in a good way, but weird all the same. I don't think I'd have been able to get totally into it but I can see why it worked.
1 reply · active 372 weeks ago
Yes it was really weird, but weird in a good way. Definitely for a specific type of audience haha.

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.