Thursday, October 26, 2017

Review: Turtles All The Way Down (And Thoughts On John Green)

WoooOOoooo. It’s a new John Green book! I mean finally, right? Well, I’ve never been one to fan over his books. But at the same time I don’t mind John Green much. And I’m not biased to rate his books highly, so hopefully you’ll get some insight from this review.

Also, I guess I was anticipating more thoughts on John Green? But I guess I don’t have any? Whoops. I mean I know my best friend absolutely loves him, but I never really interested in any of his books? The first one I read was Looking for Alaska, which I only rated 3 stars. And maybe it was just me because I wasn’t too into contemporary back then? But I for sure can say that it did not motivate me to continue reading his books. Then on the other hand, I absolutely LOVED The Fault in the Stars. I kind of sobbed through the whole thing? AND THEN THE MOVIE TOO. I remember bringing a pack of tissues into the movie theater because I knew I was just going to bawl.

A post shared by Valerie (@innocentreads) on

Seeing how much of a hit TFIOS was, I’m not at all surprised that I only liked Turtles All the Way Down. It’s true that I did enjoy it, but it just didn’t have the “umph” that it had in his last book (which yeah, I’m not surprised by at all).

On the other hand, we get to experience Aza’s mental illness firsthand, and it relates directly to the cover of the book. Her struggle with mental illness is like a never-ending, tightening spiral downwards. And even though there are times were everything is okay, sometimes it’s just not. I honestly was not expecting such a vivid experience of her mental illness, something I could very easily connect to. It’s really what made this book stand out from all the others I have read.

The plot of the story is a bit bizarre, and also takes place in the background. It starts off with Aza and Daisy wanting to claim some reward for finding a wanted man (I don’t remember exactly, I think maybe he partook in some shady dealings). Anyways, this man happens to be Davis’ father. Davis used to be friends with Aza, but they drifted apart over time. Daisy wants to use this connection to investigate, but Davis is not really onboard. He knows that everyone trying to get close to him only wants the money. Which is why right from the beginning, he hands the two of them $100k.

But Aza is like nooo, I really like you for who you are! And so, the rest of the novel focuses on the development between the two.

Overall, I really liked the book, especially how it portrayed Aza’s anxiety (although I’m not sure, it might be OCD? It wasn’t exactly labeled in the book, but I know it’s mentioned in interviews with John Green somewhere, I just don’t remember right now). But this was definitely more of a character-driven novel rather than a plot-driven one. Also, I’m not really sure how I feel about the conclusion? I almost felt like it just…ended. I guess that does reflect real life, I suppose.

In the end, I’m glad I read it and enjoyed it. It did provide a very unique perspective on mental illness.

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I liked TFIOS and Looking for Alaska was ok. I wasn't crazy about Paper Towns and DNF The Abundance of Katherines. So I am not a great fan of his books. I love the title which grabs attention. It sounds a bit confusing! I am intrigued by how he handles mental illness because we have to get rid of the stigma. Great review!
1 reply · active 388 weeks ago
My friend is pushing me to read Paper Towns, so I'll have to see how I feel about that. And I've heard similar things about the Abundance of Katherines, no one I talked to liked that one.

If you ever read this, you'll see how the title fits in! :D

Thank you!
I have this one and need to read it soon. I really love John Green's books - my favorite by him is Looking for Alaska. I get why some people aren't that into him though, so it's all good. haha I'm glad you liked the book okay! And yes, the main character has OCD (John has it too).

-Lauren www.shootingstarsmag.net
1 reply · active 388 weeks ago
Hahah I feel like I should read Looking for Alaska again, because I read it YEARS ago. And ok I thought it was OCD! Thanks for the clarification!
I'm a huge fan of John Green's books - Looking for Alaska is actually my favorite of them all, but I cried like a baby for like, twenty minutes straight after closing the last page of TFIOS. I'm not even going to get into how I was when I saw the movie, ahah, you can probably guess? :P
I ordered this one waaaaay back, pre-ordered it and I can't wait for my copy to finally arrive so I can read it. I'm really curious about that one especially, since...well, it's been a while since we have read a John Green's book, and this one is #ownvoices about John Green's own struggles with mental illness. It's much more personal and I am really curious to read this. It sounds like an intense read, at times? But I love contemporaries focused on character development, so... I think this one will be a hit for me. Let's hope so, ahah :)
Thank you for the lovely review! xxx
1 reply · active 388 weeks ago
I hope Turtles gets to you soon Marie! And hahha I totally feel you about TFIOS because I'm pretty sure I started crying once the movie started and just COULD NOT STOP hahah.

And I'm sure you will 100% love the portrayal of mental illness in this book, because it was phenomenal. Like completely made it stand out from all the other MI books I've read in the past. And I think at times it is really intense, but that's what makes it really good :)

Thank you Marie!
Yesss I could not agree more. It was good, just not "holy crap best book ever" good. But I liked it- I liked the quirkiness, but that it wasn't like, over the top. I like when a book is weird but in a way that seems... authentic? Does that make sense? But I agree about the MH rep, too. It definitely was good to see!
1 reply · active 386 weeks ago
Yes that does make sense! Like everything about the rep and the authenticity....it was good! But it just wasn't the best book I read all year hahah.
I was a little dubious when I heard he had a new book coming out, I couldn't stand another manic dream pixie girl. I've enjoyed his books previously and I was intrigued when I'd heard it was an LCD own voices represented. He's known for those crap endings isn't he. I'm glad you enjoyed it though Val, I've bought a copy too and plan on reading it over Christmas. Brilliant review <3
1 reply · active 386 weeks ago
I hope you end up enjoying it Kelly. And I'm pretty interested in what you'll have to say about it once you finish haha. SO I WILL BE WAITING <3
Very interesting take! I hear that as soon as you finish the book, the title makes sense. I'm very excited to read this myself!
1 reply · active 386 weeks ago
Hope you enjoy it as well!
I just finished this yesterday and I agree with you about the ending. It didn't really seem to have a point, other than learning to live with the struggle of mental illness, which is fine but I would have liked something a little more satisfying... it didn't have to have be all sunshine and rainbows, but just a little more conclusive I guess. But overall I enjoyed it pretty well. It was actually my first John Green book, and I think I'll definitely pick up The Fault in our Stars sometime, but maybe not his others.
1 reply · active 386 weeks ago
Yeah I definitely recommend The Fault in Our Stars, but other than Looking for Alaska, I haven't read anything else so I can't really convince or not convince you haha. And yeah, I wish the story was more ....just more in general, but I'm fine with what I got.
Yesss, I'm, glad you enjoyed Turtles the Way Down! I'm still undecided on whether I'll pick it up yet, but I've reserved it at the library. I'm glad it portrayed mental illness in a realistic way.
1 reply · active 386 weeks ago
If you get it at the library it definitely beats buying it. Hope you enjoy it Jeann!

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.