Friday, April 10, 2015

ARC Review: Shadow Scale

Shadow Scale by Rachel Hartman
Seraphina #2
Publisher: Random House Children's Books
Release Date: March 10th, 2015
Source: Netgalley
Date Read: 3/23/15 to 3/26/15
608 pages
Rating: 


The kingdom of Goredd: a world where humans and dragons share life with an uneasy balance, and those few who are both human and dragon must hide the truth. Seraphina is one of these, part girl, part dragon, who is reluctantly drawn into the politics of her world. When war breaks out between the dragons and humans, she must travel the lands to find those like herself—for she has an inexplicable connection to all of them, and together they will be able to fight the dragons in powerful, magical ways.

As Seraphina gathers this motley crew, she is pursued by humans who want to stop her. But the most terrifying is another half dragon, who can creep into people’s minds and take them over. Until now, Seraphina has kept her mind safe from intruders, but that also means she’s held back her own gift. It is time to make a choice: Cling to the safety of her old life, or embrace a powerful new destiny?

Goodreads | Amazon | B&N | Book Depository

I know I specifically read Seraphina just to read the sequel, but come on, some readers have been waiting FOREVER for a sequel. Honestly I would've thought it would be fine as a standalone, but maybe everyone else thinks otherwise.


Don't miss the first installment, Seraphina! Because as much as I hated the audiobook, I still think it was an awesome read. Plus I mean by now you must have HAD to heard about it. 

This is a pretty spoiler-free review! But I do suggest reading the first book.

Oh what to say, what to say. Let's start with the good bits. First off, we get to see Seraphina! Again! Which I can't complain about! She's on a new adventure to bring together the half dragons in order to defend Goredd from the soon to be upcoming Dragon civil war that is brewing in their homeland. Too bad one of her grotesques, Jannoula, who are all representations of real people in real life, has started causing trouble, for, oh, basically everyone. No one really knows whose side she's really on, but it can't be good.

Random Toothless gif because Toothless

I loved meeting all the new half-dragons, and also bonding with Abdo, because he is just a squishy little ball of cuteness. Oh I just want to hug him. 

However, as happy as I am for the continued adventure and the plot surrounding Jannoula and her "evildoings", I am NOT HAPPY with Lucien Kiggs. NOT AT ALL. First of all, he 1) Barely appears in the book, and when he does 2) LEAVES AFTER LIKE, what, 5 MINUTES? So yeah, I am not okay with this. In fact, my major gripe with this sequel is the ending. 



Major spoilers, highlight at own risk!

Not only does the romance barely progress throughout the story (I want to say there is none AT ALL), but that ending is literally almost the exact ending as Seraphina. 1) Lucien says he will still marry Glisselda, and 2) Orma is basically lost and still needs to be recovered, his mind at least. SO WHAT WAS THE FREAKING POINT OF THIS BOOK?

Sorry I tend to get carried away with these things


I mean honestly, I'm glad there was a sequel, and I enjoyed it immensely, I was just, oh I don't know, EXPECTING MORE from everything. I didn't get enough and now I want more and I am sad.

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I think this book was never intended to be on romance. But it does lack some of it for the sake of enjoyment. This book, though YA, is highly political. Which can frustrate a lot of people (me included) when we see no story progression. So far most reviews point that way.

I am still waiting to get my hands on it. Though I didn't liked Seraphina, I want to read this one to see the world development and the grotesques stories. Thanks for sharing!
My recent post Top 10 Tuesday: 10 Latest Books in my TBR List
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Yeah I'm going to have to agree on you with that. But I wish there was some haha. I mean the first book had more than this one? Also have to agree this is a very political book, even with the whole Jannoula plot. Hope you get to read it soon!
Ugh, I still have to read this one. Why am I so slow? That's a mystery. Anyway, Seraphin was quite okay but I'l actually a bit afraid to get to Shadow Scale's ending :/
My recent post The Narnia Book Tag
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
This book is also pretty long. And yeah. The ending was...hahahhah I think you should read it anyways!
So I read your review even though I haven't read Seraphina because I'm not really that interested with it...I know, I know! I'm sorry :( ( I didn't understand much in your review though, probably because I have no idea who the characters are :P LOL. Too bad the sequel is a slight disappointment for you...maybe there will be a third book?
My recent post Musings: I’m a Wuss of a Series Reader
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Hahahh come on Amir. Just kidding. I'm going to be honest and say that Seraphina was completely different from what I expected. And I highly doubt there will be a third book :P Maybe 10 years from now.
I haven't read Seraphina yet, unfortunately. I was under the impression this book is MG? Is it?
My recent post [509]: Give a Little by Kate Perry
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Oh I don't know? I think it's classified as YA, but since it's a classic it's on the summer reading lists of Middle graders? Not so sure.
I love the gifs you have used xD I haven't read Seraphina yet, although I should because the premise sound sound promising.
My recent post Angelfall ♥ by Susan Ee Review
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Hahha thanks Benish! Hope you get to it one day :)
I'm surprised you ended up giving this four stars! Especially since I think you gave Seraphina less? Anyhow, you know my feelings. :-/
My recent post I Read Shadow Scale and I Was Disappointed
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
I only gave it less because audiobooks :P And yeah. I did think it was good just that ending was unsatisfying. I DO KNOW YOUR FEELINGS haha
Sounds like this one was a long wait, it's just a shame it wasn't all you wanted it to be, despite the awesome new dragons appearing! I still need to read the first one, I've heard awesome things! Great review Val.
My recent post Indulgence Insider #24 – Blogger Meetups and Hauls
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Yeah apparently it was. I mean I didn't read Seraphina til this year, so I didn't have to wait at all. Hope you get to read the first one! Thanks Jeann!
I loved both of these books, but I will admit that it took me awhile to get through Shadow Scale. The whole Kiggs storyline kind of makes me want to scream, but I was happy for the small amounts that I got. I wish there was more Orma in this book though. I was really interested to see their new relationship that we only got a glimpse of in the end. Also, WHAT IS WITH THE PEARL RING?!!

Basically, I'm not over this series yet. I need one more short novella to finish off some of those story lines. Great review though; very to-the-point!
My recent post A Few Tips on Being a Master Essayist (or at least an adequate one)
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
Hahahhaha I was so happy when I got to Kiggs, but then 5 MINUTES LATER HE WAS GONE. Ugh. I also wish there was more Orma. And just more everything. OMG THAT PEARL RING WILL WE EVER HEAR ABOUT IT AGAIN. PROBABLY NOT :P

Thanks Sunny! Maybe one day we'll all get what we want :P
Aw, it's a shame Shadow Scale didn't really live up to Seraphina, which is what I've heard from a lot of bloggers. *sighs* Well, I still think I'll read it, if only to read more about cute little Abdo.
1 reply · active 520 weeks ago
ABDO. He's a squishy <3 You should read it just for him haha
I really want to try out this series as I am a huge fan of dragons.Despite my love for the creatures,I haven't read much books about them,apart from Eragon-which I love btw-and Firelight.I hope I get around to read this soon.
Great review Val!
My recent post One bittersweet urban night || Graffiti Moon by Cath Crowley
1 reply · active 519 weeks ago
Hahah that's awesome Mishma! To be honest there isn't much "dragon" in the series, well there is, but it isn't what you expect haha. Just giving you a heads up.

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.