Friday, March 4, 2016

Review: The Smell Of Other People's Houses

The Smell of Other People's Houses by Bonnie-Sue Hitchcock
Publisher: Wendy Lamb Books
Release Date: February 23rd, 2016
Source: ALA Midwinter
Date Read: 2/25/16 to 2/28/16
240 pages
Rating: 


In Alaska, 1970, being a teenager here isn’t like being a teenager anywhere else. Ruth has a secret that she can’t hide forever. Dora wonders if she can ever truly escape where she comes from, even when good luck strikes. Alyce is trying to reconcile her desire to dance, with the life she’s always known on her family’s fishing boat. Hank and his brothers decide it’s safer to run away than to stay home—until one of them ends up in terrible danger.

Four very different lives are about to become entangled.


I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

I was completely taken by surprise by The Smell of Other People's Houses, which I will now dub as "Smelly Houses", because I can, and I am not sorry.
I've realized over time that houses with moms in them do tend to smell better. If I close my eyes, I can just barely remember my mother's wildflowers in their whiskey bottles. The very distant scent of my parents lingers in my brain, as they laugh and twirl around the kitchen.

First glance at the cover, and it reminded me of Station Eleven, and of course I thought that I would be reading something similar. Luckily, I banished that thought completely, because this is not a post-apocalyptic novel.

Anyways, I think this is a really hard novel to describe. Basically, it follows a couple of characters, Ruth, Alyce, Hank, and Dora, and also features a ton of characters in the background. Ruth is pregnant with her child, Alyce is with her father fishing over the summer, but desperately wants to audition for dance, Hank is running away from his abusive father with his brothers, and Dora won a ton of money, but both of her parents are also pretty abusive. In the end, every story intertwines and meets, and it was intriguing to read.

As I said, I was impressed with the fact that I really liked Smelly Houses. Although I don't have much to say about it, unfortunately, I'm a huge sucker for books that connect everything together at the end. Which is why I loved this.

Though saying this, I do have to mention that you really have to read this all in one go. It's hard to remember what character you are on when you stop and put the book down. This wasn't really a problem in the later chapters when I figured everyone out, but in the beginning, it was bad.

Overall, I don't have much to say, other than the fact that the writing was beautiful, the story itself was short (only 240 pages! No wonder my review is so short!), and all the characters fit together nicely at the end. And that closure made me happy.

Comments (22)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Shay@TheStoryGoes's avatar

Shay@TheStoryGoes · 483 weeks ago

I'm greatly intrigued by this book. On the surface it doesn't really sound like something I'd be interested in (namely because it's set in the past and I hardly ever read ANYTHING set in the past) but the synopsis is so vague and the reviews I've seen all good and like, I feel I just need to know what's going on here. I'm also intrigued because of how short it is...and I mean, the title because who wouldn't be interested by this title???

Lovely review Val, glad you ended up enjoying this one! (though I'll never think of it as anything but smelly houses now so thanks for that) =)
My recent post Ships I Ship: The Harry Potter Edition
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Those were my exact thoughts when I started reading this book! But then I also saw good reviews and I was just like "Well why not!" And here we are. AND YES. The title was just really interesting and pulled me right into the story.

No problem. I hope everyone thinks of it as Smelly Houses and the author doesn't hate me :)
Oh wow, this sounds like an interesting book! Not because of the synopsis - that actually didn't draw me in, but your reaction to the book did haha xD "Smelly Houses"? :P
I love books that connect together at the end too - this sounds awesome! Although it does sound like it is a bit thought-consuming, because you have to focus a lot on it, from the sounds of it?
Anyway, thanks for reviewing Val - fantastic review as always! :)
My recent post The Fate Of Ten By Pittacus Lore | Ten Out of Ten Book
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Shhh I couldn't keep writing out that title, so I just abbreviated it. And I guess you do have to focus on it hahahah. Though I did have to use more brain power in the beginning when all the characters were introduced. But after that I was fine with them!

Thank you Geraldine!
Bahaha! Smelly Houses! I can't take your review seriously! :P
Anyways, I wasn't sure about this one until Shannon reviewed it. Now I need it in my life because it sounds very interesting!
And I'll have to remember what you said about reading it in one go.
I'm glad this impressed you, Val!
Fab review, Smelly Val!
My recent post Review: Blood Passage by Heather Demetrios
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
WELL SORRY.

Oh I didn't ever see Shannon's review for this! And yes do read it in one go :)

OMG I AM NOT SMELLY VAL :P
Ooh I love the cover of this one even if the synopsis doesn't really give away much info on what the book is about. Nonetheless, your review has intrigued me. Hmm, I'll have to check this one out - I too love a book that ties everything together in the end!
My recent post Riders by Veronica Rossi
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Haha that just means you should just go in blind ;) But yay! The book is really short so you should check it out!
Yes! That is such a Station Eleven cover, now that you've pointed it out!

I've been wanting to read this one - the synopsis is rather intriguing - but I will heed your advice about reading it in one sitting. Lovely review!
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Haha I'm glad I'm not the only one that thought so!

Thank you!
I love reading stories where each character's own meet and intersect. I enjoy unravelling the plot threads. :)
My recent post [616]: The Dark Days Club by Alison Goodman
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Yesss! It's fun to see all the characters meet with each other and interact :)
Oooh, I love when seemingly unrelated plot threads twine together! It's so exciting when they finally do meet at the end, because there's that anticipation building up throughout the entire book! I typically read books in one sitting nowadays (I have no self-control lol), so reading this one all at once, especially since it's so short, wouldn't be a huge issue!

Thanks for sharing- I'll have to check this one out! :D
My recent post It’s Officially Happening: A Bookish Podcast!!
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
EXACTLY. That's exactly why I love when those plots and characters come together, because there is so much anticipation :)

You're welcome!
I also adored Smelly Houses. Which I am now singing like "Smelly Cat", so thanks for that :D I agree that the writing was phenomenal, and that I was fine by the end with the characters, but it WAS a bit confusing in the beginning. There was a little "who's who" in the beginning, but since it was an eARC, I couldn't really go back and forth (which for me is the most annoying thing about ebooks, but I digress). Also, the cover is so pretty. I feel like I should probably own this book in physical form.

I am so glad you liked Smelly Houses, and that you gave it a nice nickname so we don't have to type out the real thing!
My recent post The 100 Episode 3×07 “Thirteen”
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
I'm glad you adored Smelly Houses Shannon. Omg I have never heard Smelly Cat. Is that a real song or are you just making it up. I didn't end up going back and forth, and just went along with it, and then maybe by 30% I knew all the characters.

It is a great nickname. Hopefully the author doesn't find out I'm using it.
The reviews for this have been more towards the positive side and yet I can't convince myself to read it. To be honest it doesn't sound like I'm missing much--so there's that. Thanks for this review, Val.
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
Thanks Jazmen! I definitely think it's a book that caters to a specific group of readers, so yep, it might not be for you!
I've received an ARC of this too, am so excited to read it!! Sounds wonderful. xx
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
I'm glad! I hope you read it and love it as well :)
I've seen this book around but I have no idea what it's about! I'm definitely curious because of the interesting name and the different characters' intertwining stories. Lovely review Val!
1 reply · active 482 weeks ago
You should check it out! Thanks Jeann!

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.