Friday, October 2, 2015

Review: Deathless

Deathless by Catherynne M. Valente
Leningrad Diptych #1
Publisher: Tor Books
Release Date: March 29th, 2011
Source: Library
Date Read: 9/9/15 to 9/11/15
352 pages
Rating: 


Koschei the Deathless is to Russian folklore what devils or wicked witches are to European culture: a menacing, evil figure; the villain of countless stories which have been passed on through story and text for generations. But Koschei has never before been seen through the eyes of Catherynne Valente, whose modernized and transformed take on the legend brings the action to modern times, spanning many of the great developments of Russian history in the twentieth century.

Deathless, however, is no dry, historical tome: it lights up like fire as the young Marya Morevna transforms from a clever child of the revolution, to Koschei’s beautiful bride, to his eventual undoing. Along the way there are Stalinist house elves, magical quests, secrecy and bureaucracy, and games of lust and power. All told, Deathless is a collision of magical history and actual history, of revolution and mythology, of love and death, which will bring Russian myth back to life in a stunning new incarnation.

This was...interesting. Of course I knew how lyrical the writing would be, because it's Catherynne M. Valente. But I guess because it was adult, it didn't have the magic that I encountered in her The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making series, and everything was more bleak than usual.


Also, disclaimer, I had never heard of this Russian fairy tale until I picked up the book, which is another reason why I probably did not understand half the things that happened, or why it happened for that matter. I did start to look up the original story, but that interest died after ten minutes or so.

Moving on. The story takes place in Russia, with our main character Marya Morevna wanting to escape her boring Russian life. She knows that there is magic out there, seeing domovyes (house imps) around the house and her sisters' to-be-husbands transform from birds to man, yet nothing ever happens to her. Until it does. This is similar to the Fairyland series in that the main character wants to be whisked away from her world so badly, that she doesn't think about the consequences or the regrets. 


Marya, after being essentially kidnapped by Koschei the Deathless, the Tsar of Life, begins her new life with him in his city. However, there's a war going on between life and death. And Koschei is constantly fighting, even dragging Marya along with him.

If you think this is some romantic novel, I'm going to straight up tell you that it's not. It's gritty, sex pretty much happens out of nowhere, and Marya transforms into this sweet innocent girl to a scary, yet fierce, woman. In all honestly, I find the relationship between her Koschei incredibly weird, they love each other, yet they don't want to stay together. It's almost like Fifty Shades of Grey! Not that I've read that, so it's a pointless comparison.


Also, not exactly sure what happened in the end? I thought that if I had more time to process the book as a whole, and research the original tale, I would come to an understanding. But I didn't. There is definitely symbolism throughout this entire book, explaining Russia and its surrounding countries in terms of metaphors, but unfortunately I was unable to catch on due to my lack of knowledge. Le sigh.

In the end, this was a fantastically detailed and well-written book, but I really don't know what else to think about it.

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
It sounds like you have to really have some understanding and knowledge of the Russian fairy tale to fully appreciate this. Mine is extensive so I am sure I will love this. JK! I know nothing. It does sounds interesting though. And I love your gifs although the one rolling down the hill totally made me dizzy!
My recent post Review ~ Preschooled
1 reply · active 496 weeks ago
Yeah apparently you do. HAHAHAH ok there Grace! And yes I love that gif :) It's from Gravity Falls if you're wondering (not that I have fully watched the show!)
Welp, it has a cool cover?
My recent post Jane Austen novels, ranked: A compendium
1 reply · active 496 weeks ago
To be honest Val, I don't even understand the synopsis. What does it even mean? I love retellings, even ones that are a bit dark and confrontational but I think this one might be a little too obscure for most readers. It sounds really beautifully written, but I think it's an acquired taste for people who love Russian or Russian folklore. Awesome review Val and sorry you couldn't have enjoyed this one more <3
My recent post Illuminae... Aussie Epicness!
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Umm, I don't think I would be very good at explaining the synopsis hahah. This one was kind of pretty dense, especially with the detail and the metaphors, and I didn't know what it was referring to unfortunately :(

Thanks Kelly!
This one sounds...strange. It sounds like you really have to know a lot about the original fairytale and Russia to understand things which means that's a no for me as I've never heard of this either! Honestly, I was a little confused by the description... I didn't know the author of The Fairyland books had written an adult book, of course that's probably because I haven't read the Fairyland books yet either...but soon! This comment is pointless. I am very intrigued by this fantastically detailed writing though... I'm obsessed with good and unique writing, is it worth reading just for the writing?

Sorry you didn't love this one, Val! Confusing books are the worst.

P.s. I tagged you in my Halloween tag! =)
My recent post 13 Posts Of Halloween: A Book-ish Halloween Tag!
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
She's actually written a number of adult books, I just haven't gotten to them. And I don't know if I am more willing to read them now that I have read this one? Oh well. YOUR COMMENTS ARE NEVER POINTLESS hahaha. I think it is worth reading for the writing! :)

Thanks Shay! AND I SAW. I am going to do it in a huge Halloween post :)
Ah, I always feel out of the loop when I read a book based off a tale that I have not yet read. Like, in ACOTAR, the second half of the novel is based off Tam Lin, so when I thought the WHOLE book was based off Beauty & the Beast, I was like ... what the heck? This is deviating SO MUCH from B&B. And then i did a little more researching after I'd read the book, and it all dawned on me. So i know your feels about that aspect!

It's so weird when you don't really know what to think of a book except that it was pretty and detailed. I've had that happen a few times before. It's a shame that you didn't love this one as much as you had hoped, lovely :( <3
My recent post Review: All of the Above by James Dawson
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Oh well I didn't know that about ACOTAR either. I don't even know the story of Tam Lin. Which means I'll probably just end up going in blind. Oh well. But yeah it was the same for me here! Except I feel like Valente turned the story into a huge metaphor for the real world.

Thanks Chiara :)
Gif use = A+++

I'm really incredibly excited to read this, Val, but... somewhat hesitant, now. I adore Valente's writing and the mysticality and beauty of it, but so far I've only been reading her Fairyland books and my very brief forays into her adult work haven't been so suberb. I don't know anything about the fairytale behind this story, either, and I'm hoping I'll still be able to enjoy the work without having that knowledge. Hopefully I'll be able to enjoy it simply because it's Valente and her work is so utterly gorgeous, even though you have pointed out a few things that make me unsure about the direction of the story.
Ah well. I'll try it, at least!
xx
My recent post Mini reviews (15)
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Yay hahah!

Yeah this is the same for me! I love her Fairyland books, but when I read her adult ones, I am just less mesmerized :( I loved her writing though.

But yes you should still try it!
OMG I actually love this book so much so this review crushes me a little BUT I am happy to hear you approve of the writing. I had to wikipedia and tale and reread the book after I finished it, but there are still some things up in the air for me - but I think it's because of the open ended nature of the story. It really resonated to me on an emotional and visceral level, especially the Leningrad section and the relationship between Marya and Koschei. It was never fluffy and romantic, but I found their dark and painful bond very difficult to tear away from. URGH MY FEELS.
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
I'M SORRY AENTEE I HAVE LET YOU DOWN.

I wanted to wiki it, but I was too lazy to compare the both of them side by side. And yes the for me, I didn't really understand the story, so I don't know. BUT YAY FOR FEELS. I'm glad you connected to this :)
Actually, everything you said (except the part about FSOG) is making me want to read this, though... I have ZERO knowledge about Russian fairytales, so... sigh, I'm still intrigued, haha. And I LOVE that "I regret nothing" gif. That show is totally histerical as well (it's a little stupid, but OMG I enjoy it sometimes when my brothers watch it).
My recent post Review: Slasher Girls &amp; Monster Boys
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
I have watched maybe 2 episodes of that show? IT IS SO WEIRD. And what do you mean? Just the mention of Fifty Shades should get you running to get this book hahahahhahah.

You should read this anyways :)
This is very interesting and actually fun! I adore your jokes, man :D Tbh this is very interesting and good book and i've enjoyed so much while was reading it! Although sometimes it's getting boring so yeah, i agree with 3 stars. When students need to write their essays but they don't have time for it they question themselves "who can i pay to write a paper for me". The answer is simple - writeanypapers.com writing service! Professional writers are always ready to provide you with best quality essays and research papers!

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.