Tuesday, May 29, 2018

Review: From Twinkle, With Love

From Twinkle, With Love by Sandhya Menon
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Release Date: May 22nd, 2018
Source: Edelweiss
Date Read: 5/11/18 to 5/17/18
336 pages


Aspiring filmmaker and wallflower Twinkle Mehra has stories she wants to tell and universes she wants to explore, if only the world would listen. So when fellow film geek Sahil Roy approaches her to direct a movie for the upcoming Summer Festival, Twinkle is all over it. The chance to publicly showcase her voice as a director? Dream come true. The fact that it gets her closer to her longtime crush, Neil Roy—a.k.a. Sahil’s twin brother? Dream come true x 2.

When mystery man “N” begins emailing her, Twinkle is sure it’s Neil, finally ready to begin their happily-ever-after. The only slightly inconvenient problem is that, in the course of movie-making, she’s fallen madly in love with the irresistibly adorkable Sahil.

Twinkle soon realizes that resistance is futile: The romance she’s got is not the one she’s scripted. But will it be enough?

Told through the letters Twinkle writes to her favorite female filmmakers, From Twinkle, with Love navigates big truths about friendship, family, and the unexpected places love can find you.
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

Make no mistake, I wanted to love this book so bad. Especially since I absolutely loved When Dimple Met Rishi. But this, in the end, just didn’t work out for me. And honestly, I’m 100% sure it’s a me thing.

From Twinkle, With Love introduces us to Twinkle, future filmmaker yet is somehow stuck at the bottom of the social hierarchy. Why? Mainly because she’s a bit awkward and just doesn’t fit in well with the popular kids (her family isn’t as well off as everyone else, which definitely plays a part in this too). Even her “best friend” ditched her, which is just plain rude.

BUT Twinkle has a plan. All she has to do is date popular boy Neil, then she’ll automatically be welcomed into the popular group. And her best friend, Maddie, will finally hang out with her again.

Obviously, none of this goes through. Instead of hanging out with Neil, who’s away at swim camp, she becomes close to his twin brother, Sahil. Together, they’re directing a movie for the Summer Festival.

Unfortunately, there were just a lot of things here that didn’t work for me. I know lots of reviewers are completely fine with these situations, but Twinkle’s actions and thoughts just frustrated me to no end. And so I’ll just get those out of the way first:

  • Twinkle’s intentions are a bit, well, not great, as she tries to use Sahil to get close to Neil. This is often used as a plot device, and looking back on this, I didn’t necessarily have a problem with this part. Rather, I didn’t find Twinkle’s reasoning to date Neil great. She literally wants to date him because he’s…popular? Yet she holds back on Sahil, EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE TWINS.
  • The plot itself was very predictable, and yet even though I knew exactly how things were gonna turn out, I still felt very frustrated with Twinkle’s actions.
  • I’m pretty sure I hated all the characters, except Sahil because he’s a sweetheart. Twinkle was frustrating, her best friend Maddie was also pretty annoying, the popular crew really had no reason to hate Twinkle except just to hate her (which fine, I guess you can hate someone to hate someone). I feel like the motivations for these characters and their feelings were not fully developed. Except for perhaps the main couple.
  • Also, can we talk about Twinkle’s need to set up people like a matchmaker? I’m sorry but nooooo just stop please. That’s just asking for trouble, come on now.

I’m sure there is plenty more where that came from, but let’s switch gears and talk about things I did like.

  • The relationship between Twinkle and Dadi, who I think is her father’s mother? If I’m not mistaken.
  • Twinkle’s passion for filmmaking, though to be fair I feel like the romance overshadowed that a bit. This book is written in a diary format, and she addresses each entry to a different female filmmaker/director.

Err, well I guess that is it.

Well this review ended up being me mostly venting, which means you should probably take all of this with a grain of salt. I’m sad that this just didn’t work for me, but sometimes these things just happen, where every trope in a book is just the opposite of what I actually want to read.


Have you read this yet? Am I the only black sheep for this book?

Comments (10)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I liked Dimple but didn't love it. This makes me wary of this one now though. I think I would have similar thoughts to you. I might still check it out though!
You're not alone! I DNF'd this one. I realized quickly that I wasn't the target audience for the book. The story was just too young for me. I can see how younger readers will enjoy it, though.
Aww I am sorry that this didn't work for you! Honestly I feel like those things would frustrate me too. Like- even in high school, I don't think my school was like that, you know? Popularity just wasn't a big enough deal to behave that way. And I think it's really sad that in some places it is. And I kind of feel for Twinkle because it sounds like some of these peers are awful, but then... you'd think that would be even more incentive for her to make some different choices? Idk but I think I am skipping this one. I do want to read Dimple though, in large part because she is drinking iced coffee.
I've been reading nothing but good things about Sahil :D
Anyway, When Dimple Met Rishi was mostly an okay read for me. I enjoyed it but not as much as everyone else. I can see here that they're most likely similar and it might be best that I skip this one (even though I'm seriously inlove with that cover! haha!) thanks for the honest review :)
I'm sorry to hear that you didn't enjoy this one. I haven't read it yet, but I remember how frustrating Dimple was in her book. It doesn't surprise me that Twinkle would act a bit similar in that respect. I still am excited to give this one a try. Great review! :)
I gave this one three stars. I didn't have a problem with the "I'll hang out with you to date your brother" trope, but it felt like the trope was forgotten immediately. What I didn't love was how many things Menon tried to shove into this book, I felt like nothing got accomplished.
OMG I thought it was just me when it came to having problems with this book! I mean, I know I was totally not in the right mood for it when I picked it up so it made me hella judgey about it but I ended up DNF-ing at about 25% because I just couldn't with it. I was frustrated by the predictability, which I don't usually mind but it just was a sign I shouldn't have been reading this. I ended up disliking a Twinkle a little because she was such a doormat to Maddie (who I hope she had words with about being such a bad friend) and I didn't like how she felt a connection with Sahil and continually disregarded him for Neil who barely said anything. I was pretty sure if I kept on reading I could have gotten into... but it didn't feel worth it. From what I saw I adored Sahil and I really liked Twinkle's Dadi too, so cute, she really made the bit of the book I read.
Really nice honest review! When things are too predictable and characters do very questionable things.. I'd tend to have a sour experience myself. :(
Ohhh great to read your thoughts on this Val! I haven't heard too much about this book, but I was wondering what people thought about it after loving WDMR. A shame to hear about the character niggles with Twinkle's character, I really don't get that twin thing either.
Oh, no :( I'm sorry you didn't love this one, Valerie! Especially since you loved Dimple. I really don't think you are the black sheep for this book because I've seen other reviewers have the same problems with it as you did.

I have a copy of this one coming this month, and I'm interested to see what I think because I haven't read When Dimple Met Rishi! So maybe I won't have any expectations going in. And also I've been informed of the not so wonderful things from reviews, so I know they're coming, haha.

I really love the sound of a filmmaker MC, which makes the fact that it's overshadowed by the romance quite disappointing :(

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.