Friday, January 19, 2018

Review: American Panda

American Panda by Gloria Chao
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Release Date: February 6th, 2018
Source: Netgalley
Date Read: 1/14/18 to 1/15/18
320 pages


At seventeen, Mei should be in high school, but skipping fourth grade was part of her parents' master plan. Now a freshman at MIT, she is on track to fulfill the rest of this predetermined future: become a doctor, marry a preapproved Taiwanese Ivy Leaguer, produce a litter of babies.

With everything her parents have sacrificed to make her cushy life a reality, Mei can't bring herself to tell them the truth--that she (1) hates germs, (2) falls asleep in biology lectures, and (3) has a crush on her classmate Darren Takahashi, who is decidedly not Taiwanese.

But when Mei reconnects with her brother, Xing, who is estranged from the family for dating the wrong woman, Mei starts to wonder if all the secrets are truly worth it. Can she find a way to be herself, whoever that is, before her web of lies unravels?
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

I don't think I've ever encountered as many feelings as I did with American Panda, a highly anticipated book written by an #ownvoices Taiwanese-American author. I'm not going to lie, I don't think I got out of this unscathed. But at the same time, this book will add so much to the community.

Mei is starting her undergraduate career at MIT. At only 17 years old and on the pre-med track, she's every Taiwanese family's dream. Except that she actually doesn't want to be a doctor (gasp). Instead, her passion is in dance, and her dream is to open her own dance studio. Unfortunately, chasing after her dreams leads to the risk of being disowned by her parents.


"I heard from Mrs. Tian who heard from Mrs. Lin that Ying-Na tried to make it in LA as an actress but couldn't. They even stopped paying her to take off her clothes. You're studying hard, right? Make me and Bàba proud. This is your mŭqīn."


I have many, many thoughts about this book, that it may even seem like I hated it. I really thought this would be the case in the beginning. There were so times where I read a few pages, looked up to contemplate my future or my past, spent a few minutes on Twitter, and only then was I ready to get back to reading. I'll start with the things that bother me the most, and then go from there.


Examples of Things That Bothered Me:
  • This is minor, but Mei not wearing glasses because her mom thinks they look ugly on her. Problem, is that you need glasses to see, AND to study (how can you see the board/lecture during your classes?) This is so counterintuitive!
  • I really disliked the scene where one of the characters barged into Dr. Chang's office, demanding that her chlamydia problem needed to be fixed NOW, or she wasn't leaving. Like how rude and disrespectful?

The above two are really examples of how over the top I felt this book was. For one, I'm not sure if I can explain this properly, but it felt as if all of Taiwanese-American culture was crammed within 300 pages. Every little horrible thing that happened to Mei within the first 30 pages, happened to me within maybe a year or so. I also felt like some things were very much exaggerated, for example no Asian-American goes around saying they won't be friends with you because your family killed their family in a war years ago. Furthermore, although the Mandarin is easy to understand for me, the same won't be said for everyone else. There are many Chinese idioms and phrases throughout the book, some of which not thoroughly explained, which could definitely lead to confusion.

I say all of this but once I hit the halfway mark, things started looking up. There was less setting up of the Taiwanese-American experience, and more of exploring Mei's wants and dreams. And her relationship with Darren, a Japanese-American boy who obviously her parents would disapprove of. The second half also had much more "showing" rather than "telling" overall, especially with the introduction of Nicolette and Ying-Na (my favorite character ha).

And of course, this is the point where Mei FINALLY rebels against her parents, so that's always fun. 

Overall, I still want to emphasize that this book is important. For one, and as Mei comes to realize herself, not all Asian families are the same. They are strict or lenient (or horrible) in their own way. And so obviously my experience or my friends' experiences will not be the same as Mei's. I think one of the main reasons I didn't absolutely love this, was because I related way too much to the main character (which did bring up some negative feelings, and just made this hard to read overall). For that reason, I've rounded up my 3.5 rating to 4 stars on Goodreads (I usually round down because I'm mean like that). Though I've kept the original rating here on my blog.


Also, fun note to end on, there's a random minor character mentioned in passing named Valerie, in which we find out she has a yeast infection. Obviously, I feel personally attacked J

Comments (24)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Val, what a lovely and thoughtful review! I think it's definitely an important book for sure, and I love that you were able to relate to some parts, and discuss parts that may have not been as believable for you. Also, DYING at the "Valerie with the yeast infection" bit, that is too funny 😂
1 reply · active 375 weeks ago
Yeah it definitely made this review interesting to write! And it's also the first book in awhile that I had SO MANY thoughts about, so that's always good haha. And yes I apparently had a yeast infection LOL.
So sorry this book wasn’t a hit for you! As a Chinese-American, I adored it. But ofc we come from different experiences so it’s to be expected. As for the over the top “I won’t be friends because your family killed mine in a war years ago” thing, I can attest to that- my family still even has prejudices against Japanese people after the Rape of Nanjing. (Unfortunate but true) agreed that this is an important book!
1 reply · active 375 weeks ago
Yeah that's definitely what hit me at the end of the novel, and I'm so glad that the author (and Mei!) discuss that in the book! I also can attest that my mom has prejudices against Japanese people too, though she just doesn't show it. I think for me I couldn't imagine an Asian-American/second generation saying something along those lines, but maybe that's me haha. I'm so glad you loved this book Aila!! I wish I could have said the same but oh well, will still boost it when I get the chance :D
I'm so glad that you liked this one, Val. I had a bit of a hard time with the book, but it's because I went in expecting a romantic comedy a la When Dimple Met Rishi, and this book wasn't that. It was definitely more intense than I expected. I didn't even think about that glasses thing, but so true!
Great review, Val and I agree, this will be a great addition to the community! :)
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
I WAS EXPECTING SOMETHING FLUFFY TOO! And yeah. I mean I did like this, but there were a lot of things I didn't like, yet at the same time a lot that I could relate too. (I've discussed it so much with Rashika you don't even know hahah). I'm not sure where I stand with this book, but I think I'm keeping it at 4 stars for now!

Thanks Nick!!
That was such a lovely review, Valerie! I'm sorry that the beginning wasn't the best at the beginning, but glad to hear it looked up towards the end. This book is, I think, one of my most anticipated reads, because it sounds so sweet and adorable and I am impatient to meet this main character and hear about her experience as a Taiwanese-American, too. I want to read more #ownvoices books and I am thrilled to read this one, hopefully soon :)
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Oohhhh I am excited for you to read this then! I'll definitely be looking forward to your thoughts! And yeah I did think the beginning was a bit much, but in the end it all worked out :D
Thank you for your thoughts and review of a book which was a challenge read for you. Reviews like this can be appreciated because you explained your reasoning behind your views, so well.
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
you're a dope with a yeast infection.

This is a good review. I'd give it 6/10. It severely lacked pictures of Finnikin.

I mean, you already know how I felt and like my only remark is that I disagree with you in regards to the author having to explain all the phrases and sayings. Idk, white authors don't have to and I personally felt that it didn't hinder my reading experience? People might disagree and thats their problem. I AM OUT.

Lots of poop,
Your favoritest fave
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
YES IT'S ME WITH THE YEAST INFECTION. Wooooo

Thanks Rashika. LOL you know I already know what you're gonna say. I mean tbh I felt like it hindered some of my experience and I knew most of these things? THEN AGAIN I AM A POOP and not even real so I AM OUT TOO.

<3 you
I keep seeing this and I definitely want to give it a try--although it doesn't sound like an all out amazing read--it still sounds like it worth reading!
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Yes I do hope you give this a try at some point!
Nice review, and sounds like an interesting book! And even though it had some problems I'm really curious to see what happens with Mei and her struggles to be true to herself vs her parents disapproval. Great message too that not all Asian families are one big monolithic bloc of sameness. :)
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Thanks Greg! I hope you end up picking this up :D
A couple months ago, I saw this title on Netgalley. I glanced away because 1)I thought I would go request it later and 2)there is not a big spot for contemporary romances in my heart. Then, the internet exploded with hype for this book. I read a couple reviews and yours was one of them. I think your review is so well written and focuses on specific parts that influenced your decision rather than just writing that you loved or hated it so much with no explanation. Thank you for taking the time to write a review! :)
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Thank you so much for your comment! I'm glad you found my review so helpful :D And yeah I just couldn't not talk about it because everything in this book affected me SO MUCH, that I really just couldn't keep my mouth shut :D
It's so hard for a book to meet expectations when you know it's one which will feel at least a little personal to you so this book obviously suffered slightly from your own expectations. That being said, it does sound like a really good read and a good champion for having more diverse reads out there in the world. Sure, the first half may have crammed a little too much in (maybe a bit more refinement needed there) but the second half sound like it was a great read. And isn't weird how we all say we want more characters we can relate to in books but when one hits a little too close to home we often dislike it because we relate too much? I've definitely noticed I have that sometimes and I always find it such a weird thing to be bothered by yet I am all the same.
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Hahah yes I totally agree! I definitely related so much to Mei, but I think only to her cultural background. Like her personality, and her actions, are totally not me. It's not until she rebelled was I like "now here we go, finally" did I really get into the novel. But yeah it is sooo common! And it happens, nothing we can do about it haha.
Hi,

I'm so excited to share the first chapter of AMERICAN PANDA, which was recently revealed on Bustle! Check out the excerpt here or click the photo below! And the preorder campaign will be announced soon—stay tuned! American Panda
I think I saw this cover recently and thought, "that's cute" and skipped it because I assumed it would be something fluffy so I'm kind of surprised to read how intense it is. Being Asian-American myself with a mom that also tried to push me toward being a nurse or doctor (groan) I'm actually curious about this book. Definitely adding this to my TBR, thank you for the detailed and thoughtful review!

Also on the prejudice about war, my mom actually used to yell at middle school me for watching anime and listening to jpop because of the war. Ranted about how her grandfather died defending the Philippines from the Japanese, so it happens sometimes.
1 reply · active 374 weeks ago
Oh yes you should read this! I think you would 100% relate. My mom never pushed me to be a doctor, but she REALLY wanted me to be a computer engineer (because she was one, and my dad was one, and blah), and I was learning computer software in..maybe first grade. It was interesting.

OH yes I agree! I just thought it was very weird for another Asian-American to say these things, like someone my age or younger/second generation. My mom never really showed much prejudice towards the Japanese, but I do know that when she first moved to the US, she kind of didn't view Taiwanese people as Taiwanese, but as Chinese? She knows better now, but it was really interesting to find that out about her. Also I think my friend's mom had a problem with her going to Japan for study abroad? But she went anyways haha :P

Thanks for the comment!! I hope you pick this up soon :D
It's always hard when a book ends up being too much of a mirror. I have a couple of titles like that on my bookshelves (but only after I read them, gave them away, made peace, and then ordered myself copies when I realized I actually did want to look at them again one day).

I'm going to be recommending this one A LOT once my library gets copies and it comes out but I'm still on the fence on if I'll be reading it myself.

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.