Friday, April 22, 2016

Review: When We Collided

When We Collided by Emery Lord
Publisher: Bloomsbury USA Children's
Release Date: April 5th, 2016
Source: ALA Midwinter
Date Read: 4/7/16 to 4/10/16
352 pages
Rating: 


We are seventeen and shattered and still dancing. We have messy, throbbing hearts, and we are stronger than anyone could ever know…

Jonah never thought a girl like Vivi would come along.

Vivi didn’t know Jonah would light up her world.

Neither of them expected a summer like this…a summer that would rewrite their futures.

In an unflinching story about new love, old wounds, and forces beyond our control, two teens find that when you collide with the right person at just the right time, it will change you forever

I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

This is going to hard for me to review. Again. I actually do have a lot of things to say, but I'm struggling to find a way to say them all, without being offensive. Especially since features a main characters with bipolar disorder.

Maybe I'll just say it straight? Ok? Ok.

So, I guess this is kind of a disclaimer in that I don't know anything about bipolar disorder. I used to think it was as simple as "oh you change moods super easily". But I'm sure that's not what it is.

Anyways, Vivi has bipolar disorder, but she's skipping out on some of her medication because of the side effects. She has just moved to this wonderful little beach town called Verona Cove, where she meets Jonah, who is struggling with his own problems. This includes taking care of his three younger siblings, while working. With his mom rarely getting out of bed, and his two older siblings working and at college, it's incredibly hard for him to juggle all the things.

And along comes Vivi, who completely turns his world around. She comes up with the craziest ideas with the kids, like a scavenger hunt, or a Slip n' Slide. And at first glance, Vivi is such a great character. She loves kids, she knows how to have fun with them. I like kids, I don't know if I'm any fun but let's just assume kids love me (They do).


But then there are just some things here and there that have gotten under my skin.

Like the fact that Vivi gets jealous when Jonah talks to other girls. Or in this case, it's his friend, from work. Whose father is really good friends with his late father. In which he was asking her for advice on how to make the family restaurant better. Like you are allowed to have relations with the opposite sex.


And then a lot of Vivi's decisions have been a little....crazy I suppose? And I couldn't get behind how she was treating Jonah at times, brushing him off and not respecting him at times. And I guess what is really bothering me is that I find it hard to criticize her without sounding like...well, an asshole. It is obvious that her bipolar disorder comes into play, and I know that excuses her actions. But unfortunately, I couldn't just ignore the feelings I had in regards to this novel. How am I supposed to know which thoughts were Vivi's, or the bipolar disorder? It was frustrating. (Cue discussion post!)

The rest of the novel I did like, though it was a little out of my comfort zone. In the end, it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be. Like I really loved the fact that the characters were well developed. Jonah just wasn't just some guy, and Vivi actually had more going on than her illness.

I don't regret reading this, and I'm sure I'll enjoy more of Emery Lord's books in the future, but I think this was just a little too much for me. 

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I completely understand how you feel! I really enjoyed Vivi at the beginning but then she acted sort of crazy towards the end. I thought the bipolar disorder was portrayed really accurately in this book. I've seen a few bipolar patients and they have the same manic and out-of-control energy that Vivi had. But I have to agree that she did act like a bit of a bitch for quite a large portion of the book and it was kind of hard to like her....

Jenna @ Happy Indulgence
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
Yeah I'm glad this was portrayed so accurately! I'm sad that I didn't end up liking Vivi, but at least I got to know more about bipolar disorder!
I love your thoughts because it really does show whether it was confusion over the characters' illness or their personality. I like how you say she was unlikable but you couldn't really differentiate. Lovely review Val!
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
Thank you Jeann! I'm glad I was able to get my thoughts out!
I was really looking forward to this book because I LOOOOOOOVED The Start of Me and You, but this book is SO different. Like you, for me Vivi seemed like a fun character at first, but she definitely spiraled to out-of-control proportions and I wanted to scream at Jonah BREAK UP WITH THIS GIRL. It aggravated me at the end, but at the end I thought maybe the problem was what I expected from the story. I went in expecting a love story but instead it was a story about real tough issues and heartache. Maybe I wasn't really supposed to ship them. Like you, I'm glad I read it, as it definitely got me thinking, but it wasn't what I was hoping for.
My recent post Ten Books Every High School Student Should Read
2 replies · active 475 weeks ago
I actually haven't read any of her other novels! But glad to hear that this is the only really different one. I also really wanted to scream at both Jonah and Vivi. I also was expecting a love story, but...I don't know. I don't know what my expectations were. Thanks for the comment Amy!!
I can't speak for Open Road Summer, but I think you would definitely enjoy The Start of Me and You WAY more. It's very sweet and cute.
My recent post Reading Habits
A little bit more heavy than her usual contemporary, I suppose. i just bought this, and now, I'm a little hesitant to start.
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
I wish you the best of luck! I mean maybe you'll like this more than me?
I've been hearing various things about Vivi, but I've also heard people have been really loving Jonah. Verona Cove sounds so dreamy! I can kinda/sorta relate (?) (but probably not really) to VIvi because I do get crazy jealous at times, but the blatant disrespect toward Jonah sounds totally uncool. Terrific review!
My recent post Review: The Way I Used To Be
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
Yes I actually really liked Jonah! He was such a hardworking kid, taking care of pretty much everyone. And I would LOVE to live in Verona Cove! Thank you Peach!
You make such a good point here. The fact is that we need to treat people with mental health issues with respect and understanding, but that doesn't mean that we have to like all their actions. And since I have an issue with books with unlikeable main characters, I'm not sure how I'd feel about Viv. I'm off to go read your discussion now ...
My recent post Sunday Post & Giveaways Galore 4/24/16
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
Haha thank you Nicole! Do you think you'll be reading this? And yeah I think it's okay that we don't like a character's actions, even if they do have a mental illness.
You did it! *showers you with confetti* I am still putting off writing my review for this book, because I just don't know what to write. >.<

I also didn't really like a lot of Vivi's actions, and it IS really hard to determine which actions were affected by her bipolar disorder, and which actions she was doing because she genuinely wanted to. A lot of the things she did didn't really sit well with me, but that's hard to say because of what you mentioned. Am I an asshat for saying that?

Good job with writing such a tough review, lovely!
My recent post Simply Sunday (#30)
1 reply · active 475 weeks ago
THANK YOU CHIARA! <3

Well if you DO write it, I cannot wait to read it :) And no I don't think you're an asshat, I think we're allowed to express what we're feeling. Even if it means criticizing someone like Vivi.
Okay. Finally had time to give this my full attention. I agree with you about Vivi being really problematic. Partly I think that was intentional but partly I think it wasn't a great character portrayal. In general for books with characters who have a mental illness I am quite tired of the "I can't take my meds because they'll make me a different person" trope. It's tired and played out and inaccurate and damaging. I was disappointed after hearing so much praise for Vivi's authentic portrayal to see that a lot of her arc hinged on not taking her meds--especially when that problem is so easily remedied by talking to a professional.

I agree that Vivi was weirdly jealous and make a lot of bad decisions. The problem is that it's impossible to explain why really. We never really see Vivi when she's on her meds. It's safe to say even from page one that some manic tendencies are influencing her choices. Because of that it's impossible to separate who Vivi is when her bipolar disorder is not being treated from who she is regularly--we as readers don't have enough information.

A lot of the great things about Vivi were also completely invalidated for me because of the really sloppy side plot with her biological father. I HATED THAT SIDE PLOT. Everything about it was messy and contrived and either not explained well or just not accurate.

I had a hard time with Jonah's side of things too though because it hit a bit close to home. His story felt much more moving and authentic to me.

Overall I think this book did a lot of good things but I think the editing process might have been a bit rushed and as a result the book wasn't as strong as it could have been. I enjoyed parts of it--especially that it was almost an anti-romance in places--but I think it got a pass in a lot of ways because of the positive portrayal of a girl with bipolar disorder and because Emery Lord is so well-liked as an author (which is totally deserved but I think also often minimizes valid concerns).

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.