Thursday, August 10, 2017

Review: The Girl with the Red Balloon

The Girl With The Red Balloon by Katherine Locke
Publisher: Albert Whitman Company
Release Date: September 1st, 2017
Source: Netgalley
Date Read: 7/12/17 to 7/15/17
256 pages


When sixteen-year-old Ellie Baum accidentally time-travels via red balloon to 1988 East Berlin, she’s caught up in a conspiracy of history and magic. She meets members of an underground guild in East Berlin who use balloons and magic to help people escape over the Wall—but even to the balloon makers, Ellie’s time travel is a mystery. When it becomes clear that someone is using dark magic to change history, Ellie must risk everything—including her only way home—to stop the process.
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review. Quotes taken from ARC may or may not be in the published edition.

It’s a miracle! I’m writing this review one month early! Wow!

Let me get right to it. Overall, I did like this one. Time travel, WWII-themed (though to my surprise, not actually set during WWII), magical red balloons, all of this just screams me. Though to be completely honest, me and this book did not get off on the right start.

1% into my eARC and already I was seriously judging the simple writing style. Meeting our main character, Ellie, felt a bit lackluster, all tell and no show. I was afraid that this writing style, and therefore this book, wouldn’t work for me at all. Fortunately, that didn’t end up being the case as after 2%, the writing changed and started to appeal to me.

I also must admit that my expectations were set really high, even though I have never read any of the author’s older works before. If you don’t know by now, but I try to read anything and everything related to WWII. Even though this didn’t necessarily take place during that setting, it is still set during the time of the Berlin Wall. This came as a shock, as 1989 wasn’t so long ago, and I had thought the Berlin Wall was brought down earlier.

The Girl with the Red Balloon had a solid plot and solid characters. And time travel of course! I was impressed and surprised with Ellie’s actions, despite the fact that she so badly wanted to go back home. Kai and Mitzi were also wonderful additions to the book, though to be honest I’m not sure whether I cared about the romance between Ellie and Kai.

More could have been developed, especially in regards to world-building. I’m a bit fuzzy on the details of the balloon makers. I’m assuming that there will be more in the sequel, or companion book, as this one is only 256 pages. There were also times where I was confused on who was on who’s side. Though perhaps this was due to my lack of knowledge in history or just the terms used.

Either way, I did enjoy this! Not sure if I will pick up the “sequel”, but I’ll think about it!

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I've had my eyes on this one for a while now, but was waiting to read reviews first. I'm so glad that the writing turned out to be better for you after 2% (OK i totally giggled at that, Val!). I'm very intrigued by the setting and all the characters. I didn't realize it was part of a series, but I hope you get your wish of more solid world building.
1 reply · active 395 weeks ago
BUT IT WAS TRUE. Like the first few pages read like a really bad contemporary, and I was like "please don't let the rest of the book be like this". And then the MC gets whisked away, and the writing completely changes thankfully.

I think this could definitely be read as a standalone! You'll just have to deal with the incomplete worldbuilding.
I did see what Locke said about this being a stand-alone, and how other books will be set in this world. I would be ok with new characters, as long as they kept the Balloon Maker part going, because we definitely do not have the whole story there, and it was a really interesting start. Overall, I enjoyed this book as well. My family history is so entrenched in WWII history and I had relatives who used to help people escape from the east as well.
1 reply · active 395 weeks ago
Yeah the Balloon Maker part needs to be expanded on. I'm glad you enjoyed the book as well!
WHO is the amazing human being who told you that the writing got better? I can't seem to recall... ;) But no, I loved this book. I just... I want an epilogue. Or a sequel. Or a novella. Any would do.

Also, if you were born in say, 1982, you'd remember the Berlin Wall thing being "a big deal", and you'd know that David Hasselhoff was involved, and you'd be mildly bummed that he was paid no mention in this book.
1 reply · active 395 weeks ago
I know I just read your review of thissss. I still need to comment on it. AND STOP BEING SO SALTY. You have a mention in like every other one of my reviews. Chill mom.

Who is David Hasselhoff? Is he important? Should I know about him?
I'd not heard of this one but it sounds vaguely interesting. I have that with books sometimes, the first few pages do not work for me and I debate putting it down but once things get going I adjust. I hate when there's not enough world building because I want things to feel real when I'm reading and to feel like the author has an entire world in their head, not just bits of one. I may check this out as it is an interesting concept but I may hold out and see if I'm still interested in a few weeks time.
1 reply · active 395 weeks ago
Yeah that's a good idea. I usually wait until around 100 pages before I decide on whether to put it down or not, but it was such a short read that I just finished it. But unfortunately that did mean the worldbuilding just wasn't there, or wasn't really as developed as I wanted it to be.
I had seen this one around but hadn't bothered to read a blurb. I do love a time travel book. Glad the writing got better pretty quickly!!! Great review!
1 reply · active 395 weeks ago
Okay between yours and Shannon's reviews, Val, I definitely will be sticking with this past the first 10 pages. :P I feel like 1% is such a drastic change for writing styles! Anywho, I'm always intrigued about time traveling books and I love how this one really puts these recent histories in a reader's face. If you decide to pick up the sequel, I really hope it gets better!

- Aila @ One Way Or An Author
Wow! You must have enjoyed reading the entire story with a solid plot. I used to feel that it would be too difficult to make corrections in my Aadhar card, but when I visited here -uidaiaadhaarcard.com, it proved me wrong, and made it easier for me to update the information on the Aadhar card.

Post a new comment

Comments by

This site uses IntenseDebate to manage comment data. Learn more about how that is processed here.